Author Topic: Question regarding braid and mono in terms of light spinning  (Read 4569 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline PRENO

  • Ultimate member
  • ***
  • Posts: 240
  • Cred: 7
  • Gender: Male
  • Location: Bluff, Scottburgh
Question regarding braid and mono in terms of light spinning
« on: January 14, 2021, 10:06:28 AM »
Hi Guys


So I have a question, with regards to spinning from shore (light tackle)
For the use of braid for spinning, is it because of the diameter and the reels can take much more braid than mono or is it for some other reason? like cast better, distance, backing, personal preference, someone told you its better than mono, you can feel the bite better or other


I tried both braid and mono for spinning, as I do not cast that far as I am not targeting any big fish.
My problem is with braid, although the the reel takes around 300mt 15lb braid, it is not as strong as the mono when you snag a rock or the braid get stuck on a mussel, it tends to cut off very quick, even though you have a braid leader and fluorocarbon leader and if you do not cast correctly, or the braid tangles around an eye, the braid snaps on cast, loosing good spoons and lures and the time it takes to redo the whole knot tying is time consuming.


With mono, although the line capacity is less on the reel, I never had an issue with it and landing distance is almost the same after cast, just mono to fluorocarbon leader with a quick change clip, never lost a spoon or lure.


For Rock and Surf fishing I only use mono as I feel it works better for me.


Now is it worth spending that amount of money for braid? because I have spent a lot on braid which to me seems like a waste of money now.
What are your thoughts and experiences.




 





Family is happiness

Offline RiyadhEd

  • Senior Member
  • **
  • Posts: 141
  • Cred: 3
  • Gender: Male
  • Location: Cape Town
Re: Question regarding braid and mono in terms of light spinning
« Reply #1 on: January 14, 2021, 10:33:28 AM »
I have braid on my reel, topped with mono. The only reason the braid is there, is for when a fish pulls out all my line. I prefer using mono as a main line. I know quite a few people fish with braid, but its not for me. I reckon it differs from person to person

Offline Half-Pint

  • CHAMPION ANGLER 2014
  • Ultimate Champ
  • ****
  • Posts: 3712
  • Cred: 223
  • Gender: Male
  • Location: Boksburg
Re: Question regarding braid and mono in terms of light spinning
« Reply #2 on: January 14, 2021, 02:49:02 PM »
Braid casts better, has better bite detection, gives more line capacity. The list can go on.


Equivalent pound braid will be less abrasion resistant by virtue of it being much thinner. If I ask you to saw through a 10mm piece of wood or a 20mm piece of wood which will break first?


Remember that braid is not just a straight swap for mono. If you are breaking off on casts or wrapping line around your guides something is wrong with your set up.


Once you use a properly set up outfit with braid you are unlikely to go back to mono for spinning

Offline Lenny

  • Ultimate Champ
  • ****
  • Posts: 2529
  • Cred: 124
  • Gender: Male
  • Catch and Release
  • Location: Struisbaai
Re: Question regarding braid and mono in terms of light spinning
« Reply #3 on: January 15, 2021, 07:22:48 PM »
One more thing .


Your setup needs to be right , in order to get the most out of braid , it Often , I matter of spending , and paying school fees , on what works for YOU .


Loads of articles and threads , that will give you some direction .




I , have actually , gone back to mono , on SOME of my lighter tackle .


The main reason are , I like the stretch in mono , and when your trying to catch larger fishing on lighter mono , the stretch helps me a lot when fighting fish , but I quess it might just me and my crappy way of going about things .


When if comes to distance in casting , yes braid all the way .


One has to relize , that because braid , has no stretch , it’s harder on the reel , it’s harder on the rod , and harder on the back .


So by saying , braid , you also have to commit , to maintance on your reels , MORE often than with a multiplier , as 98% of the guys fish braid with spinning / grinder reels .


With mono , you can catch fish on a , really in expensive  rod and reel , but with braid , be weary , not saying it’s going to cost , a lot more , but gereally you’ll pay more .



Self catering , family accommodation available  in Struisbaai . Contact Leon 0780394225

Offline Lenny

  • Ultimate Champ
  • ****
  • Posts: 2529
  • Cred: 124
  • Gender: Male
  • Catch and Release
  • Location: Struisbaai
Re: Question regarding braid and mono in terms of light spinning
« Reply #4 on: January 15, 2021, 07:25:34 PM »
Shoe , forgot to say .


My light outfits , I reverted back to mono , are lines from 6 to 12 lbs , generally for rivers and harbours .


You will get , served , repeatedly over the rocks with such , thin mono . Thinnest I have gone , or what I would suggest , is at least 20 lbs ..
 But be warned
Self catering , family accommodation available  in Struisbaai . Contact Leon 0780394225

Offline fishatic

  • Ultimate member
  • ***
  • Posts: 500
  • Cred: 14
  • Gender: Male
  • Location: Randpark Ridge, Johannesburg
Re: Question regarding braid and mono in terms of light spinning
« Reply #5 on: January 16, 2021, 09:53:52 AM »
Shoe , forgot to say .


My light outfits , I reverted back to mono , are lines from 6 to 12 lbs , generally for rivers and harbours .


You will get , served , repeatedly over the rocks with such , thin mono . Thinnest I have gone , or what I would suggest , is at least 20 lbs ..
 But be warned



So you use 6lb and 12lb mono in the harbour and rivers?
20lb mono for the rocks (minimum)

Not sure of brand but for example

Kingfisher Giant Abrasion (on paper fantasic dia/strength)
6lb = 0.20mm
7lb = 0.21mm
10lb = 0.25mm
12lb = 0.28mm
15lb = 0.30mm
20lb = 0.35mm 25lb = 0.40mm

Maxima Ultragreen:
6lb = 0.22mm
8lb = 0.25mm
10lb = 0.30mm
12lb = 0.32mm 
14lb = 0.35mm
18lb = 0.40mm
20lb = 0.42mm

If say you matched 12lb mono to braid in terms of dia, you would be using 30lb J Braid that breaks at 50lb.

Inasmuch you like the stretch of mono and of course it is personal, but if you had to match actual diameters you would get the following results for (Daiwa J) braid:

0.19mm = 8lb stated actual breaking strength 18lb

0.23mm = 10lb stated actual breaking strength 24lb

0.27mm = 15lb stated actual breaking strength 28lb

0.29mm = 20lb stated actual breaking strength 37lb

0.325mm = 30lb stated actual breaking strain 50lb

0.37mm = 40lb stated actual breaking strain 60lb

0.42mm = 50lb stated actual breaking strain 65lb

You are giving up a lot of strength.
« Last Edit: January 16, 2021, 10:04:55 AM by fishatic »

Offline Lenny

  • Ultimate Champ
  • ****
  • Posts: 2529
  • Cred: 124
  • Gender: Male
  • Catch and Release
  • Location: Struisbaai
Re: Question regarding braid and mono in terms of light spinning
« Reply #6 on: January 17, 2021, 09:37:50 AM »
Shoe , forgot to say .


My light outfits , I reverted back to mono , are lines from 6 to 12 lbs , generally for rivers and harbours .


You will get , served , repeatedly over the rocks with such , thin mono . Thinnest I have gone , or what I would suggest , is at least 20 lbs ..
 But be warned



So you use 6lb and 12lb mono in the harbour and rivers?
20lb mono for the rocks (minimum)

Not sure of brand but for example

Kingfisher Giant Abrasion (on paper fantasic dia/strength)
6lb = 0.20mm
7lb = 0.21mm
10lb = 0.25mm
12lb = 0.28mm
15lb = 0.30mm
20lb = 0.35mm 25lb = 0.40mm

Maxima Ultragreen:
6lb = 0.22mm
8lb = 0.25mm
10lb = 0.30mm
12lb = 0.32mm 
14lb = 0.35mm
18lb = 0.40mm
20lb = 0.42mm

If say you matched 12lb mono to braid in terms of dia, you would be using 30lb J Braid that breaks at 50lb.

Inasmuch you like the stretch of mono and of course it is personal, but if you had to match actual diameters you would get the following results for (Daiwa J) braid:

0.19mm = 8lb stated actual breaking strength 18lb

0.23mm = 10lb stated actual breaking strength 24lb

0.27mm = 15lb stated actual breaking strength 28lb

0.29mm = 20lb stated actual breaking strength 37lb

0.325mm = 30lb stated actual breaking strain 50lb

0.37mm = 40lb stated actual breaking strain 60lb

0.42mm = 50lb stated actual breaking strain 65lb

You are giving up a lot of strength.




I made suggestion , as to should you go the mono route , as the first post ,on this thread , was about lighter gear .


What I was trying to , bring over , diameters means ZERO , or how much would compare , or to use your words , match .


I think keeping mind , that the post was started by , a person that from his questions does understand , there are a diffrance in diameters , break strains and actual breaking strain .


You also know , like I know m that just by making those calculations , the variables , are so vast , that there’s so much info .

Self catering , family accommodation available  in Struisbaai . Contact Leon 0780394225

Offline fishatic

  • Ultimate member
  • ***
  • Posts: 500
  • Cred: 14
  • Gender: Male
  • Location: Randpark Ridge, Johannesburg
Re: Question regarding braid and mono in terms of light spinning
« Reply #7 on: January 17, 2021, 10:17:49 AM »
I disagree about the diameter meaning zero.

Comparing ABS is the problem, a braid that breaks at 20lb is half the thickness of a mono that breaks at 20lb; you cannot expect the braid to handle the same physical abuse (abrasion) as the mono.

Dia makes a huge difference when it comes to casting performance on a spinning reel. A thinner line means the spool empties more slowly and results in it having to climb less ato the spool lip s the overall circumerferance shrinks slower, nett result you cast further with a thinner line.

Interestingly, braid's softness and leack of memory also assists in this regard.
The OP's remark that a braid that breaks at 15lb (actual, not stated) braid being weaker than a mono that breaks at 15lb?How? 15=15.

Are their other characteristcs that make a difference? Yip.

The braid is much, much thinner (0.19mm vs 0.35mm) and can be abraded or cut easier, I think this is the more likely scenario.

Now if you were to say match diameters, swap your 15lb braid for a 50lb, you would bump up dia to around 0.32mm - 0.35mm, toughness would go up exponentially.But there's a couple of trade offs:
1. less line (would be the same as 15lb mono)
2. Casting distance would drop off (byu OP said it was not important)
Beyond this, if you prefer mono, that's fine.
It's your preference!
« Last Edit: January 17, 2021, 10:37:07 AM by fishatic »

Offline FishStyx

  • Ultimate Champ
  • ****
  • Posts: 3007
  • Cred: 51
  • Gender: Male
  • I fish, therefore I am.
  • Location: Louist Trichardt, Limpopo
Re: Question regarding braid and mono in terms of light spinning
« Reply #8 on: January 17, 2021, 11:30:15 AM »
I haven't fished with mono in years... When I've been on a boat and the dedicated boat rods (trolling outfits), all with mono on, start to scream and I've picked up and tried to set the hook, it's like you're tied to the fish with a rubber band. Also, trying to pump and reel down, there's nothing but stretch that you're reeling down on... Nah... Braid all the way for me. Can't see myself ever buying mono again. That being said, I don't really do much rock and surf, so perhaps I'm commenting from an entirely different perspective.
Forgive me Father for I have spinned... It's been three weeks since my last cob session.

Offline travelmember

  • Ultimate Champ
  • ****
  • Posts: 663
  • Cred: 49
  • Gender: Male
  • Location: Cape Town Western Cape
Re: Question regarding braid and mono in terms of light spinning
« Reply #9 on: January 17, 2021, 03:47:13 PM »
OP - what reel are you using and what braid is on the reel?


I suspect that the equipment may be more of an issue rather than braid vs mono.
However to answer your initial question (and that is based upon where you are and the fact that you are casting close for smaller fish) - Braid is preferred as you can drop in diameter for the same breaking strength. Less diameter means you can cast smaller lures and you can cast further. And yes, you can also fit more onto the reel. Along with this, some other advantages are that it lasts longer (5 years vs 1 year on average) and that due to limited stretch you can "feel" what is going on with the lure better and you can feel delicate bites. So, for light tackle spinning for most smaller species, braid is the way to go. I don't bother with a casting leader, I prefer a short length (the length of the largest fish I aim to catch) of fluoro direct to the lure.


However, like Lenny, for some species and methods I find braids non stretch properties to actually hinder rather than help. Casting lures for big game fish that jump (tarpon, sails) then we will fish mono.
And for real light line record fishing I find braid useful for backing but not for fishing - the lack of stretch is too unforgiving. Also when sight fishing in crystal clear water, I prefer straight fluoro as braid is too visible.
Finally when I am fishing with lots of obstacles (rocks, pilings) then something like Maxima is preferred.


But the issues you mention sound more tackle related than just the braid.

Offline PRENO

  • Ultimate member
  • ***
  • Posts: 240
  • Cred: 7
  • Gender: Male
  • Location: Bluff, Scottburgh
Re: Question regarding braid and mono in terms of light spinning
« Reply #10 on: January 27, 2021, 09:54:23 AM »
Hi Guys


Thanks for taking time to reply.


The only rod and reel that have braid on it so far is the Ceymar 40 and Penn Allegiance 2 7ft.
I have 20lb braid as I fish inshore as well for Shad/Elf


I have realized that when the braid was spooled by the tackle shop, it was spooled incorrectly. It has been rectified but I did not get a chance to use it thereafter.
When I do, I will let you guys know.







Family is happiness

 

SimplePortal 2.3.7 © 2008-2026, SimplePortal