0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
Quote from: SilverTip on January 15, 2013, 12:50:10 PMQuote from: Ray Hall on January 15, 2013, 12:33:50 PMim referring to bronzies here... flatfish on a beach different story. What the diffs, both fish has limited life once hooked, but stick to the rule, work the fish harder for a quicker landing, cut the trace if you can’t return the hook and try not to keep the fish out the water for more than 2 min. and as a skipper, I know how short 3 min can be, not to mention 2 min. but then I have to agree with you if you don’t want to hurt the fish, don’t fish. But at least do your best to get it back in the water without doing it unnecessary harm. Protect what we have, because it all we have!!!100%
Quote from: Ray Hall on January 15, 2013, 12:33:50 PMim referring to bronzies here... flatfish on a beach different story. What the diffs, both fish has limited life once hooked, but stick to the rule, work the fish harder for a quicker landing, cut the trace if you can’t return the hook and try not to keep the fish out the water for more than 2 min. and as a skipper, I know how short 3 min can be, not to mention 2 min. but then I have to agree with you if you don’t want to hurt the fish, don’t fish. But at least do your best to get it back in the water without doing it unnecessary harm. Protect what we have, because it all we have!!!
im referring to bronzies here... flatfish on a beach different story.
There is no point in gaffing a flat fish as this would cause tremendious damage to the fish, sharks again sensative, definatly not ooff the beach as you can just straight stick the fish right onto the sand and if anything use a rope around the tail to help you again this is a sensative subject (rope on the tail) for me the answer is that there are no two situations that are the same and the angler has to use his judgement in each case as weather to gaff or not
I don't think its fair to say that everyone against the gaff has no idea of pulling big fish in difficult conditions. Mazeppa has seen many bronzies blackfins etc landed off the island that's 6 to 7 meters deep straight onto the ledge. Easy? No! Possible? Definitely! I'm the furthest thing from a big strong guy and I managed it the normal argument is that yes an experienced angler can do it but not a novice. Well I don't know too many novices who know how to gaff a big fish safely. As I said before there are places and situations where a gaff may be better but those situations are few and far betweenGood post Bradley !
Thanks for all the comments, really not trying to make a fuss here...just actually couldn't believe people still gaff.I do feel strongly against gaffing as we also get giant fish up here in KZN (as do the rest of the country), huge flat fish, giant sandies, blackfins, zambies and more with a diversity of beach and point structures, deep lips, drop offs, and and and and....so respectfully I dont believe that this is a good enough reason to gaff...anyway....Sometimes we have to look at what we do, and I personally have supported the non gaffing culture because of the fact that we are going in the right direction so to be honest, maybe we shouldn't fish where we cant get fish out without a gaff....2c.......
Hi Shaun,I'm sorry bud, you still drag a fish up the rocks when it is gaffed..with or without a lethal point in its vitals, a few scratches, the fish can live with, especially Raggies as they hunt in the rocky areas for things like Galjoen and Blacktail. If you watch the show, the fish swim back ALIVE with NO vital damage done. So respectfully, we take really good care of the fish, no matter where we are, edible or NON EDS. That comment was not positive. Look I know this is a touchy subject, but we do so much for our FISHING FOR THE FUTURE progress and to have anglers gaffing fish just seems to be going backwards to me. That's the last I will comment on this, everyone has their own opinions and for those who carry a gaff, I hope you take an extra 10,20,30,40 minutes to get your fish out than stick that gaff into it, that's angling! and getting fish out without a gaff should be part of the sport ;-)