SAfish - being a lawyer - I look at things legalistically. Even a net is illegal, and no licence? And, when poor subsistence fishermen take illegal fish, or when people strip the rocks of mussels because they are hungry, or when the skelms take illegal fish - its all the same.....even if a family is in dire straits and takes illegal fish - thats a crime. Otherwise we could say that anyone in dire straits can burgle your house, steal your car etc etc because they are in need
That the garrick was going to die anyway is also irrelevant - not an argument that will succeeed legally. If a kudu is being stalked by a lion, can you shoot it (without a licence) because it was going to die anyway? So, in the extreme scenario, would murdering an old person be justified - because he was going to die anyway.
So not mudslinging - just extrapolating