ULTIMATE ANGLING - the Ultimate SA Fishing website
General Angling Topics => Shore Angling => Topic started by: sardinella on January 23, 2012, 07:59:55 PM
-
Any news on the mouth possibly breaching?
Please post if you have info
-
no news much more water needed
-
thanks - lets pray for more water
-
or they grow a pair and open the mouth or direct the umfolozi river behind the dune into the lake
-
What still lives in the estuary other than crocs? (if the crocs are there I assume that there must be a food source for them) Did the fish that were trapped in the estuary when the mouth closed have any chance of survival?
-
Here is a pic a friend of mine took of the mouth this weekend - they wanted to hire a boat to go fishing and were told there are no fish in the estuary :-( . Hope this helps.
-
What do u mean there's no fish in the estuary??? The B-team caught all the winning edibles in the estuary with the B-day bash ... :rck" :rck" :rck"
-
What do u mean there's no fish in the estuary??? The B-team caught all the winning edibles in the estuary with the B-day bash ... :rck" :rck" :rck"
:rotfl Sorry Jakes ... maybe the woman at the boat hire place was talking :nobs: without the stripe?
-
What do u mean there's no fish in the estuary??? The B-team caught all the winning edibles in the estuary with the B-day bash ... :rck" :rck" :rck"
Ja , but all those B-team fish were very sick and confused. You should be ashamed of your team for catching them !!!! :crzy :crzy :crzy
-
Ok chaps I have just been chatting to some friends of mine and this is going ahead, they are actually digging up the mouth as we speak with some heavy machinary. This is also in anticipation of the severe weather expected over the next few days. So lets hope the efforts are going to be good enough for this to push the mouth of the estuary completely open.
This is an Isimangaliso initiative, so thats good news. The next worry is being able to keep the mouth open once its open, but baby steps!!
-
Ok chaps I have just been chatting to some friends of mine and this is going ahead, they are actually digging up the mouth as we speak with some heavy machinary. This is also in anticipation of the severe weather expected over the next few days. So lets hope the efforts are going to be good enough for this to push the mouth of the estuary completely open.
This is an Isimangaliso initiative, so thats good news. The next worry is being able to keep the mouth open once its open, but baby steps!!
Awesome news!!
-
Check out www.zululandobserver.co.za (http://www.zululandobserver.co.za) . There's an article there in yesterdays edition abt linking the Umfolozi with the estuary.
-
Wonderful news.
The cyclone heading to "Southern" Mozambique might just do the job! (Hope it spares the Moz people any loss or suffering).
The mouth should have been opened and kept open (dredged or sucked) years ago. The ecologists arguments against the "artificial" opening is probably the weakest case I have ever heard in my life.
-
Will post some pictures after work
-
Spoke with a mate in st lucia , they started digging yesterday, and hope to open it today!!!!
-
Okay guys went down to the beach there is only one excavator and the machine doesnt sound mechanically any good spoke to one of the kzn chaps there and he said that they hope they can move a dozer and front end loader onto the beach butt there is still a sh@$%t load off sand that needs to be moved and i honestly think that they are waisting their time and money with only one machine . I recon that they have moved about a 1000m3 off sand in two days.Lets hope keep the prosses going till the water flows.
-
Thanks for the pics and update Cyclone... ++cred! Keep us posted as to developments!
-
Will do Reefs
-
That's great!. Pity it's neap tide but let's hope the swells will keep it open this time.
-
Thanks for the update Cyclone. Thats still an awfull lot of sand to go.
This coming cyclone can of course just dump more sand and close it again.
-
my liwe bliksem
dit gaan reen, duidelik soos daglig
-
Yip. It's been dry in KZN but we would like rain in moderation. Let's hope damage will be minimal.
-
ph, fyn, baie fyn gedink daar.
he he
-
Thanks for the pics and update.
St Lucia needs an open mouth badly - economically and fishing wise
-
Update was down at the beach this morning but no excavator maybe these okes dont work on weekends and the surf has also picked up
-
:tkx: :+ cred:
Please keep us posted
-
Sorry, in Afrikaans - courtesy of Beeld newspaper.
In short, Ezemvelo KZN have decided to channel the Umfolozi into the lake again so that it can raise the level of the lake to assist with breaking through to the sea:
uMfolozi gaan weer uitmond in merestelsel 2012-03-02 23:08
Durban. – In ’n ommekeer van die bestuurspraktyk van die St. Lucia-vleiland, Suid-Afrika se heel eerste wêrelderfenisgebied, gaan die uMfolozirivier vir die eerste keer in sowat 60 jaar toegelaat word om in die merestelsel uit te mond.
’n Wal wat vroeër jare met laaigrawe tussen die twee mondings gegooi is om te keer dat die rivier- en St. Lucia-monding by die strand saamsmelt, word nou verwyder.
Die reën en groot branders wat die naweek verwag word wanneer die tropiese storm Irina die KwaZulu-Natalse noordkus bereik, kan die uitmonding van die rivier in die meer moontlik aanhelp, het mnr. Andrew Zaloumis, uitvoerende hoof van die iSimangaliso-vleilandparkowerheid, gesê.
Sedert die uMfolozi se monding in November verlede jaar oopgestoot is, het die rivier se loop by die strand 330 m noordwaarts na die St. Lucia-monding verskuif.
Daar word verwag dat die rivier aan die bopunt van die strand in die meer sal invloei.
Die uMfolozirivier is in 1952 kunsmatig van die St. Lucia-merestelsel afgesny nadat vleilande naby die uMfolozi se monding ná die Eerste Wêreldoorlog drooggelê is om suikerrietlande in dié vloedvlakte te vestig.
Volgens Zaloumis sal die samesmelting van die twee mondings ’n kernrol speel om die natuurlike dinamika van die St. Lucia-ekostelsel as ’n strandmeer te herstel.
Omdat die rivier so ’n groot opvangsgebied het, sal dit ’n beduidende bydrae tot die invloei van vars water in die merestelsel lewer.
In die laaste paar jaar is ’n groot groep wetenskaplikes byeengebring om die bestuur van die St. Lucia-stelsel te hersien en koppe bymekaar te sit oor die dinamika van so ’n strandmeerstelsel.
Volgens wetenskaplikes is daar natuurlike jare lange siklusse waartydens die monding van die strandmeerstelsel van nature oop, vernou of heeltemal toe is.
Dít hang van die siklusse van droogtes, vloede en siklone af.
Die stand van die monding bring veranderings in die vars- of soutgehalte van die mere mee wat elk verskillende ekostelsels onderhou.
Dit is hierdie verskeidenheid wat daartoe bygedra het dat die stelsel tot wêrelderfenisgebied verklaar is, het Zaloumis gesê.
-
net jammer daar is geen masjiene wat grou nie
-
hou duim vas.
genoeg reen sal dit natuurlik oopmaak.
het nog altyd gese, ons kort n ander damoina.
irina is net vyf na d, sekerlik tyd.
hoop daar is baie reen met min skade.
ss
-
Well the mouth is still not open and the umfolozi hasnt breached into the lake still raining hard and the wind is still up
-
Holding thumbs.
-
How is the level of the lake compared to the mean sea level. Higher? Lower?
-
Seems the storm is not as intense as was predicted, still hoping for a miracle regarding the river mouth!
-
http://www.facebook.com/# (http://www.facebook.com/#)!/photo.php?fbid=331330193584447&set=oa.10150577076813366&type=1&theater
Looks like its open (clap) :rck"
-
Rainfall Figures for the first 24 hours of tropical storm Irina:
Kosi Bay - 249mm
Sodwana Bay - 274mm
Mantuma - 64mm
Cape Vidal - 325mm
Charters Creek - 320mm
False Bay - 189mm
St Lucia - 285mm
Recently and in fact very recently, so recent that the event is not over. We are still experiencing the effects of Cyclone Irina. But this Tropical storm started of with dumping an average of 300mm of rain along the eastern part of the iSimangaliso Wetland Park. This storm redefined torrential, it rained non-stop for hours on end. The rain was whipped about by blustery winds, fortunately not too strong. The hamlet of St. Lucia survived this event. In the morning as the clouds briefly cleared the extent of the rain was clearly visible.
The level of the estuary jumped almost a meter overnight. During the next week seepage will add to this raised level. Now we are waiting to see the effects of this raised level and whether the mouth will open naturally or the current attempt to dig open the mouth, will finally reconnect this remarkable Eco-system back to the Indian Ocean. Currently all the St. Lucia residents are making regular trips to the estuary mouth to see what is happening.
The biggest change might not necessarily be the lake but more to the north.
All the rain has created maybe a thousand or more lakes along the whole extent of this Park. There is little or no damage, maybe a flooded road here and there, but for the most the Park is open. Open to visitors and the open water that has formed over night has attracted thousands of waterbirds. A real Cinderella situation. This event happens every 20 to 25 years on average. Although in 2000 we had a similar situation, lakes and lakelettes formed all the way from St. Lucia to Cape Vidal. As it was then, it is now virtually possible to paddle all the way from St. Lucia to Lake Bhangazi just outside Cape Vidal. Although we might need to take a rain check on that one. Maybe one of these crazy reality extreme outdoor guys could do it, crocs and all.
So for the next year or so, we will be able to appreciate a wetland like no where else in South Africa.
-
Unfortunately its still not open, a bit of a bummer was the digger breaking down, so there was not as much digging done as originally planned.
But the levels are rising so lets hope it is enough for it to push through, and maintain it enough for at least a couple of full tides, so that it can scour it open.
-
Hey Shag,
Is the Digger bust for good??
No replacement or mechanic?? I'm battling to understand this logic....
-
Hey Shag,
Is the Digger bust for good??
No replacement or mechanic?? I'm battling to understand this logic....
There is not to much logic used mate, I think they were undergunned in the first place with only one machine, they started digging thursday and the machine packed in on afternoon, so weather it is repaired or not I have no idea, or maybe they are waiting to see what happens with all the rain :dunno: :dunno: :dunno:
-
the mouth is a long way from open but still raining here have bailer from sodwana Rose bowl has been cancelled
-
the mouth is a long way from open but still raining here have bailer from sodwana Rose bowl has been cancelled
you can come have some fun at Vidal. bring brave pills and lifejackets..
-
cam down to st lucia today but bailing back home this sitting around is no good for my liver
-
Looks as though they have started to dig again...............just got word from St Lucia locals...........
Lets hope this effort works...........
-
How soon will this affect the fishing?
Lets say that we are planning a trip to Vidal in August, should we move it to St Lucia/Maphalane?
-
Last time the estuary opened in March 2007, both the Umfolozi and St Lucia estuaries were open to the sea. The carnage that happened at St Lucia was not a pleasant site. Check the anglers lining the estuary... bag limits? What bag limits? Shad and Grunter were plundered in their thousands... not to mention the absolutely disgusting state that the beaches were left in... the stench was nauseating. :-(
Millions of discarded Sardine heads rotting in the sun and pilchard boxes for Africa.
-
i'm feeling it.
it's gonna happen soon, very soon.
the mouth should open, just give the water a chance to run down.
and, with it, the fish will return.
ss
-
Just heard that the Mouth is open :happ:
-
Just heard that the Mouth is open :happ:
Great news! Let's hope it stays open
-
Photos please - anyone?
This is great news :happ:
-
bump
-
Dit lyk my die manne wil nie met ons die nuus deel nie. :dunno:
-
they still digging as far as i know but here people are catching fish as they are all congreating at the bottom for the breaching. water washed in during high tide yesterday think this must have triggered it off
-
Thanks Rory. :shre:
Keep us posted if U can.
-
hope you guys have your bookings in order.
mine is in.
just waiting for time to pass.
now, he best of both worlds, shore and off shore.
lekker ne
ss
-
just heard from a resort manager that the mouth is well and truly open and the fish are going ballistic eating anything thrown at them. My booking for easter is done :happ: :happ:
-
Thanks for the good news Shaheen. Please keep us Vaalies updated.
This calls for a celebration!
Photo's anyone?
-
Thanks for the good news Shaheen. Please keep us Vaalies updated.
This calls for a celebration!
Photo's anyone?
Sure, here you go Clive ... :hnthnt: ... Let's hope they stick to their bag limits and release all the breeding stock ... :rotfl
-
My dearest Jakes,
Thank you for the photo of St Lucia mouth now open and the euphoria going on there.
Thats horrifying!
But we must never forget, we live in/on a continent where 90% of the inhabitants (or more) have no job or income.
With the exception of one or two I've spent some time in every country in Africa, and you want to mention the words "bag limits" there? Where people are hungry and children are suffering everything that moves gets eaten. Sometimes even those that dont move any more are also eaten.
I sometimes think we're under the impression that we live in so called "first world" Europe or America. They maintain "bag limits" there but dont care one iota about bombing countries like Iraq and Afghan back into the previous century, and not one damn for the collateral damage caused in the process, all in the race for controll over the worldsenergy resources and so that America can be the only country in the world to posses nuclear weapons.
So, are we wasting our time practising catch and release and/or adhering to bag limits, cause what you release is just going to end up being eaten down stream?
Had a request from a friend in Angola who asked that we must please stop putting those silly plastic strips on the fish. It melts in the pan or otherwise gets stuck in their throats.
So the moral of my story, We live in Africa and must get used to it. Eat or be eaten, and most importantly: Steek maar moenie doodsteek nie (Make love not war)!.
-
My dearest Jakes,
Thank you for the photo of St Lucia mouth now open and the euphoria going on there.
xxxxx xxxxx
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Steek maar moenie doodsteek nie (xxxx xxxx xxxx)!.
Sorry Clive, ek kon nie lekker hoor wat jy se nie maar ek dink ek het die belangrikste gedeelte van jou boodskap gekry ... :hyst: :hyst: :hyst:
-
Jakes, jy't die belangrikste gedeelte darem gehoor. Ons moet na outydse waardes terugkeer. Dinge was toe beter!
Elk geval:
JAKES CIRCA 1972
-
:hyst: :hyst: :hyst: :hyst: :hyst:
-
To throw a spanner in the works .... i wonder if the mouth wuold remain open till the U.A bash in November ...... :hnthnt: :hnthnt: :hnthnt: ........... hmmmm Mapelane just a down the beach...... :hnthnt: :hnthnt: :hnthnt: ............. :creep: :creep: :creep: :creep: .
-
I would not mind going to Mapies again. :creep:
-
To throw a spanner in the works .... i wonder if the mouth wuold remain open till the U.A bash in November ...... :hnthnt: :hnthnt: :hnthnt: ........... hmmmm Mapelane just a down the beach...... :hnthnt: :hnthnt: :hnthnt: ............. :creep: :creep: :creep: :creep: .
Not sure about November but you'll have a better chance of it still being open in July ... :hyst: :creep: :creep: :creep: :hyst:
-
yip, july should still be good.
has anyone have proper pics.
that seems like "kenia"
-
Any photos please :-)
-
sorry chaps. it appears that we have been fed some serious misinformation. a very good friend of mine went to st lucia today and he reports that the mouth is not open. all that happened was a small spill appeared, and closed, and people thought the mouth opened. sorry again for posting incorrect info. my bad sry sry sry
-
the mouth is open, although it was done manually, with earth moving equipment.
a channel was dug from the umfolozi to the river
do a search on google, it's there.
-
the mouth is open, although it was done manually, with earth moving equipment.
a channel was dug from the umfolozi to the river
do a search on google, it's there.
Its most definately not open. spring high spilled a bit but really that 1 excavator is not enough.
-
jean is the channel from the umfolozi to the estuary open
-
dalk moes ek dit gestel het. Die proses is aan die gang.
Al is dt net 1 excavator.
Daar het op n stadium water in die meer ingevloei.
Net n kwessie van tyd.
-
Andrew Zaloumis CEO of St Lucia said on the radio this morning that the lake had risen 1/2 meter with the rains last week and that they hope that the mouth will be open soon
-
Rory it depends what your definition of a channel is :-)
they need to open it up quite a bit before the river will connect freely to the estuary.
regarding the surf spilling remember its spring tides, high rainfall and not even that was enoughi
-
Andrew Zaloumis CEO of St Lucia said on the radio this morning that the lake had risen 1/2 meter with the rains last week and that they hope that the mouth will be open soon
zaloumis is ceo of isimagoliso, and think that there world heritage site is under threat as they have not done anything to help the situation there funding is on the line. to dig a trench is not the most difficult not sure why this is all taking so long
-
yip, and as far as i know, the states gave 7 million dollar.
wonder whats left of it?
daai mond moet nou oop kom
ss
-
I think we are about to see a huge swr up, I can almost guarentee that this mouth wont be open soon, they will stop digging operations as they have missed there gap with the natural phenomenon like the cyclone, and isimangaliso will withdraw again behind a cloud of bureacracy and red tape...watch this space, so sad.
-
I think they thought robson was coming to vidal and He would be paying for the fuel bill for the excavator.
-
yip, and as far as i know, the states gave 7 million dollar.
wonder whats left of it?
daai mond moet nou oop kom
ss
It was the World Bank - not the States that gave the money as far as I know
-
world heritage people and much more than 7 million
-
I think they thought robson was coming to vidal and He would be paying for the fuel bill for the excavator.
Your right, and we would have paid for it no problem except they wanted us to pay 30k for filming and have a 5 minute interview with "bongani", I ask myself how the hell can you interview one of there okes for that long its bad enough trying to discuss daily things with the guys!!
"aai errmmm well yis sir as a as a as a metter of fect"........ :cry: :cry: :cry: :cry:
-
zaloumis is ceo of isimagoliso, and think that there world heritage site is under threat as they have not done anything to help the situation there funding is on the line. to dig a trench is not the most difficult not sure why this is all taking so long
My mistake about Zaloumis - Yes I know he is the CEO of the park - not the town.
From the limited reprots I have heard, they have done significant work in regenerating the surrounding wetlands, removing trees and buying up land etc. This is a long term project, the damage that has been done over the decades will take a very long time to sort out - opening the mouth is only a part of the solution
-
Spot on Ziggy
A lot of work has already been done.
Isimangaliso should approach some of the corporates for assistance - Bell or RBM or some of the other mining or timber companies might be happy to help out - Imagine a few mean Bell machines making short work of the sand and getting a lot of front page exposure to boot - or maybe I'm just daydreaming. :-(
-
the area was ear marked for international tourism with a finger showen to us south africans and it has not worked, st lucia as a town has taken huge strain as the result of this, no driving on the beach no estuary to fish in. the locals have battled as no one to buy the crafts and so forth. if the mouth and beaches open it will be very busy again and every one will benifet from this
-
Some years ago we had a chat to one of the KZN Parksboard members at their offices at Mission Rrocks just after the area became a World Heritage Site. It was explained that the area was now "property" of the wider international community and, as such, will be administered by international agents to maintain the standards. Apart from recent upgrades at Vidal to accomodation, one wonders how effective this "supervision" is.
The same goes for Kosi Bay. We always wanted to visit the area, but have been advised from various sources that it's not worth it anymore. A great source of income for the local communities - tourism - is being suppressed by short-sighted attitudes.
Let's hope that St Lucia opens to the sea and stimulate the local economy again.
-
SOme of the local sugar cane guys would have helped if asked....
I personally miss the days, years back when you were having a drink at the bar and a old cruiser came down the street with a shark tied to the bull bar( know it was not right). The place was festive and always on the go... grunter run then shad run then garrick run.... wow i miss it..
-
The place was festive and always on the go... shad run .... wow i miss it..
I had the privilage to witness that in the late 70's.
-
The place was festive and always on the go... shad run .... wow i miss it..
I had the privilage to witness that in the late 70's.
Me too those were the days, used to camp on the wall and fish the night incoming tide, caught many a fine kob and grunter, the bull mullet were so thick next to the wall you could almost walk on them, giant sharks beaching whilst chasing the mullet in the shore breat, wow memories are flooding back, cheers
-
yip some good memories to have had.
but opening the mouth, via by mankind will not last long.
sad thing is, the system needs water from the back to keep it open. and there aint not much rain.
it would be nice to put some dollosse to keep the mouth from running north. but they need to be 'submerged"
if does open, some good fishing awaits us.
lekkerrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr
-
For official Isimangaliso updates on the mouth see
http://www.isimangaliso.com/index.php?readnews+7225 (http://www.isimangaliso.com/index.php?readnews+7225)
and
http://www.isimangaliso.com/index.php?readnews+7226 (http://www.isimangaliso.com/index.php?readnews+7226)
-
For official Isimangaliso updates on the mouth see
http://www.isimangaliso.com/index.php?readnews+7225 (http://www.isimangaliso.com/index.php?readnews+7225)
and
http://www.isimangaliso.com/index.php?readnews+7226 (http://www.isimangaliso.com/index.php?readnews+7226)
Excellent links Ziggy! Thanks for sharing! +cred!
-
Another one.
Understanding the problems at St Lucia
-
Another one.
Understanding the problems at St Lucia
VERY interesting reading Ziggy ... :shre:
Contrary to popular belief it's not as simple as opening up the mouth and keeping it open. I for one have never really understood the problem but now I do.
-
Another one.
Understanding the problems at St Lucia
VERY interesting reading Ziggy ... :shre:
Contrary to popular belief it's not as simple as opening up the mouth and keeping it open. I for one have never really understood the problem but now I do.
After reading the document I came to the conclusion that the interests of fishermen and farmers (who both want the mouth open) are short term and do not contribute to the overall long term recovery of the lake system. It is both those short term interests that have contributed to the ecological mess that we now have.
From a layman's point of view - I think that the current strategies to deal with the problem are sound - but I don't think I will be alive to see the ultimate benefits as a fisherman - but at least my descendants will!
-
Yup, brilliant article Ziggy...!
Amazing to see the lengths the authorities have gone to to try keep the Mouth open!! Including those dolosse placed in the 80's. Amazing stuff. Can't stop the forces of nature though, no matter how hard you try, be it drought or floods. The biggest problem facing keeping the Mouth open is that in the drought season, the salinity in the Lake increases to such an extent that it cannot sustain life!!
So it seems that the primary focus is to link the Umfolozi to the estuary behind the dunes, thus keeping the salinity down.
-
Thanks for the info Ziggy. The bottom line is that you cant mess with Mother Nature! We are currently paying for people trying to influence nature years ago. I have grown up spending many of my formative years in the St Lucia/Cape Vidal area and have seen the steady decline over the years. I have followed this saga closely over the last 10 years. I have fished on a unique tagging project at Cape Vidal for the last 10 years and witnessed the decline of fish like Grunter and Stumpies on the project, as a direct result of their nursery area being inaccessible. I went up to St Lucia this weekend to see for myself exactly what they have done and are trying to do. Like all other St Lucia fans i was excited with all the talk of trying to resore the system. Boy was i dsappointed!!!!
Those of us who remember the St Lucia of old will remember the Umfolozi joining the system at Honeymoon Bend....about 500 or so meters up the estuary from the mouth. This ensured that the mouth would be assisted in opening during times of heavy rain. Upon investigation this weekend, it appears that they were trying to link the 2 systems along the dune line on the beach. You cannot divert a river flowing at capacity with sea sand! This was always going to fail and was a token gesture to the locals in my opinion. If Mr Zaloumas and his merry troop were serious about this matter they would make an effort to divert the system back to Honeymoon Bend area!
It is amazing what a little bit of positive news can do for a town. If Isimangaliso would just make a serious effort, the town will return to its former glory as a holiday destination. Most importantly, the fish using the system as a nursery facility will be able to do so......a win win situation for all involved.
-
:+ cred: Ziggy some great articles
-
Those of us who remember the St Lucia of old will remember the Umfolozi joining the system at Honeymoon Bend....about 500 or so meters up the estuary from the mouth. This ensured that the mouth would be assisted in opening during times of heavy rain. Upon investigation this weekend, it appears that they were trying to link the 2 systems along the dune line on the beach. You cannot divert a river flowing at capacity with sea sand! This was always going to fail and was a token gesture to the locals in my opinion. If Mr Zaloumas and his merry troop were serious about this matter they would make an effort to divert the system back to Honeymoon Bend area!
If you go on to the Isimangaliso website and click the "downloads" tab - you will find some informative documents - like the iSimangaliso GEF project Specialist Scientific Workshop attendance list andiSimangaliso Umfolozi_St Lucia Investigations Literature reviewed (also check out the other documents such as Background Information on iSimangaliso GEF Project andLake St Lucia: understanding the problem and finding the solution) you might want to review what you said above (my red highlights)
I would say that the serious research done and the serious group of scientists working on the issues indicates that they are being pretty serious about the matter - not to mention the serious amount of money that is, for the first time ever, being spent to try and fix up the mess
As a layman I would not second guess them - especially not with anecdotal evidence - I would also say that if this was a "token gesture" on their part - its a pretty expensive one. And, would they do this only to provide a token gesture and not attempt try to solve the problem?
-
I fish with some very serious scientists as well.....they do not concur with the opinions of Isimangaliso....it seems you can 'seek' the opinions you need when scientific theory is required. I hope for the sake of all stakeholders that they get it right.
-
I fish with some very serious scientists as well.....they do not concur with the opinions of Isimangaliso....it seems you can 'seek' the opinions you need when scientific theory is required. I hope for the sake of all stakeholders that they get it right.
I wouldn't say that too loudly - because it does impune the reputations, objectivity and professionalism of the scientists involved - and suggests that they may be operating for motives other than solving the problem.
Have the scientists you refer to peer reviewed the significant research done? And have they published this non concurrence? Have they formally researched and published alternatives? If so, I would like to see their views, and alternatives.
One of the bigger problems around St Lucia is that there are too many experts who have solutions - but I just don't see them coming up with a programme, project, research that can withstand scrutiny.
I still say, let the experts do the work.....take another look at who these experts are - I doubt whehter any of them would agree to provide opinions that do not accord with rigorous scientific research.
...but maybe I am naive....?
-
Just a thought - if Isimangaliso was not being serious - what exactly are they trying to do - what is their motivation?
Is it they that do not want to solve the problem? I doubt that very much.....
-
Ziggy.....with all due respect....you need to go there yourself and see what they are attempting. You will see how futile it is and you will see that it will never work. That is why i went there this weekend. Spend some time with the local oldtimers as well and gauge their opinions. Nobody understands the system like they do. Sometimes 'scientific investigation' looks for problems which are very easily solved. I had a few beers with some local oldtimers at the skiboat club on Sat afternoon. Their opinions make sense. When asked why the system could not be rerouted to the old entrance to the lake, they gave some half baked excuse about local inhabitants who are farming in areas that would be affected. Law states that no formal farming may take place in areas below the 'flood line' of the past 50 years. We all know of the influence the ANC has on certain Isimangaliso leaders......draw your own conclusions!
-
I would assume that the "local old timers" you refer to are not scientists but fishermen who have a short term view of a long term problem - and I would therefore not concur with their opinions unless backed by scientific fact derived from proper research by proper accredited scientists within a consultative investigative process.
From the documentation I have seen so far, it would appear that there was involvement of the residents, business people etc of St Lucia town in the design of this long term project to regenerate the lake.
As for the influence the ANC has on leaders? I wouldn't know about that really - but, again,I would say that it impunes the professionalism of the scientists and practitioners involved. It is always easy to bring politics into the situation. Can you be more clear about what this influence is on what issues and what leaders you refer to? I would be interested to know. This may change my (and others) opinion on what is happening
Maybe we should get the Isimangaliso authorities involved in this debate - they would be best placed to provide the answers to the objectivity of the scientists and research done - and the inferences of political interference.
-
good luck phoning them
-
You are misinformed of the 'consultative process'. Whatever is being done is without the knowledge of the locals.....ask any of them and they will tell you this. With regards to the influence of the ANC, without naming names, a high ranking Isimangaliso official has had a long standing relationship with the ANC. I find it hard to trust the intentions of any politically linked individuals, no matter who they are. The oldtimers that i refer to do not have a 'short term view of a long term problem' as you put it. What they have witnessed is a healthy sustainable system degererating into an unhealthy environmental disaster, based not on any scientific study, but rather on the visual and physical impact it has had on their lives. Their solution has no scientific rational but rather basics.....return the system to the way it was! How much simpler could it be?
-
You are misinformed of the 'consultative process'. Whatever is being done is without the knowledge of the locals.....ask any of them and they will tell you this. Surely they have a municipal Councillor and other structures that represent them - tell hem to get report backs - that's how democracy works
With regards to the influence of the ANC, without naming names, a high ranking Isimangaliso official has had a long standing relationship with the ANC. You have evidence of this relationship of course?I find it hard to trust the intentions of any politically linked individuals, no matter who they are. And what would those intentions be - to destroy the Lake or to regenerate it?
The oldtimers that i refer to do not have a 'short term view of a long term problem' as you put it. What they have witnessed is a healthy sustainable system degererating into an unhealthy environmental disaster (Phew, they must be REALLY old to have seen a healthy system - because the problem started in 1911 when the Mfolozi floodplain began to be converted into agricultural land for sugar cane farming - in the late 1920s, a system of drainage canals was built. By the 1940s concern was being expressed about sedimentation in the mouth region, which was attributed to the canalisation of the Mfolozi River. In the early 1950s the combined mouth closed and there was extensive backflooding. This was dealt with by artificially breaching the mouth ) , based not on any scientific study, (my point exactly!) but rather on the visual and physical impact it has had on their lives. Their solution has no scientific rational but rather basics.....return the system to the way it was! (EXACTLY WHAT ISIMANGALISO ARE TRYING TO DO!) How much simpler could it be? Well, it cannot be more simpler than the scientists are proposing - its just that a lot of people don't like the solution because it affects their short term interests and needs. Any simpler will just make things worse! Lets be realistic, the processes being currently undertaken are not for the benefit of our or the old timers generation, its for our descendants!
-
I respect your opinion.
-
Ziggy, thank you for a well reasoned and thought through response. I am sure that Mr Zaloumis and his team are trying to come up with a long term sustainable solution, but am afraid that the damage is irreversable.
They will have to decide, do they want a freshwater/brak lake, or do they want an estuary where the ocean fish can come to breed. If the latter, the solution is simple - open the mouth and keep the mouth open.
Regarding Kosi, wish Mr Zemoulis had the same enthusiasm and became urgently involved to stop the over fishing, poaching, and rape of the estuary. That is after all their job.
-
I respect your opinion too!
-
@ ziggy
to answer your question regarding the motivation for the current work being done at the mouth, rumour has it that if the mouth is not open by june this year, st lucia will lose its world heritage status and of course the dollars that go with it. :dunno: :dunno:
-
@ ziggy
to answer your question regarding the motivation for the current work being done at the mouth, rumour has it that if the mouth is not open by june this year, st lucia will lose its world heritage status and of course the dollars that go with it. :dunno: :dunno:
that sounds a lot more plausible than just a token gesture to the St Lucia residents - or some other political agenda.
Maybe their funding (and the related business plan and project schedules) dictates that the mouth should be opened - who knows!
However, rumour is not always right!
-
opening the mouth is a short term sollution.
we are currently have a very dry spell of rainfall.
the lake needs water from the back to open the mouth successfully and to keep it open.
so, when it is open well catch some fish at least
ss
-
opening the mouth is a short term sollution.
we are currently have a very dry spell of rainfall.
the lake needs water from the back to open the mouth successfully and to keep it open.
so, when it is open well catch some fish at least
ss
A simple analysis of a complex situation - nicely said! especially the last bit - "when its open, we'll catch some fish at least"...sieze the moment when you can.....
-
Some more interesting reading on the matter:
http://www.iol.co.za/news/south-africa/kzn-wildlife-accused-of-holding-back-nature-1.251609 (http://www.iol.co.za/news/south-africa/kzn-wildlife-accused-of-holding-back-nature-1.251609)