ULTIMATE ANGLING - the Ultimate SA Fishing website
General Angling Topics => Shore Angling => Topic started by: J-Rock on June 10, 2011, 02:04:19 PM
-
George - “Ek het sy vin sien uitsteek toe hy in die hoofstraat voor ons huis verby geswem het.”
Só het ’n jong man van Groot-Brakrivier vertel wat Woensdag ’n meter lange leervis op die krieketveld voor sy ouerhuis gevang het.
André Carstens (18), ’n matriekleerder aan die Hoërskool Punt op Mosselbaai, het die leervis omstreeks 14:00 gewaar. Die vis het uit die strandmeer in die dorp se rigting geswem toe die walle van die rivier weens die swaar reën oorstroom het. Die water was in daardie stadium heuphoogte voor die huis.
André het gister vertel hoe hy en ’n paar ander manne hul bes probeer het om die vis aan te keer toe dit in Langstraat, Groot-Brakrivier se hoofstraat, vin gewys het.
Volgens ’n ooggetuie het die vis op die middelstreep van die pad afgeswem en ’n U-draai voor die huise gemaak.
André, ’n kranige hengelaar, is deur sy drie broers aangemoedig om die “ou grote” vir aandete te vang. Hulle is vyf kinders in die gesin – vier seuns en ’n babameisie wat vroeër vandeesweek gebore is.
André het gister opgewonde vertel hoe hy die leervis vyf uur lank agtervolg het, en oor die krieketveld voor hul huis agter hom aangeswem het.
Die vis het duidelik sy pad na die strandmeer probeer terugvind, maar toe die watervlak begin daal, is hy in die waterpoel op die krieketveld vasgekeer.
André het die vis uiteindelik met ’n net aangekeer en aan die stertvin beetgekry net voor die vis die net geskeur het.
“My pa moes my kom help. Dit is die grootste leervis wat ek nog gesien het – 8 kg, en sterk! My hande is stukkend gesteek.”
Sowat 60 motoriste het langs die pad stilgehou en met hul selfone foto’s van die ongewone vangs geneem terwyl André met die vis teruggestap het huis toe.
Ten tyde van al die opwinding was sy ma, mev. Odie Carstens, in die kamer met sy babasussie. Sy het gesê dit is beslis ’n tyd wat sy nooit sal vergeet nie, want dis nie aldag dat ’n vin voor jou slaapkamer verby beweeg nie.
Volgens mnr. Johan Carstens, André se pa, het die vis vorentoe gesmaak met ’n bietjie botter, knoffel en suurlemoen.
-
:-)
-
:shk
-
:shk
That's what i call lucky
-
Extremely J!!!! I guess the rain is good for a few things :hehe:
-
I told you guys to come and fish from my balcony! :hehe: :grk: fshg
-
I told you guys to come and fish from my balcony! :hehe: :grk: fshg
We're coming. Just gotta pick up some :beer: :beer: :beer: 1st & I might even bring my cricket bat... :hehe:
-
OK we have Rock and Surf, Offshore and so on what category is this one :hehe:
-
:hehe: :hehe: so Hermann now we can play cricket, drink beers watch the Lions win and catch Leeries! Awesome!
-
News flash: The Proteas have a new coach - Garrick Kirsten. :hehe:
@WK - I would not mind going out with only 6 on the score card!! :grk: :grk: :grk: :grk: :grk: :grk:
-
:hyst: :hyst: :hyst: :hyst: :hyst: :hyst: :hyst: :hyst: :hyst: :hyst:
-
OK we have Rock and Surf, Offshore and so on what category is this one :hehe:
we'll call it street fishing, since apparantly they swim up the road make U-turn's and then head out for some cricket action. :hehe:
-
:hehe: :hehe: so Hermann now we can play cricket, drink beers watch the Lions win and catch Leeries! Awesome!
That sounds like one Helluva weekend to me... :happ:
-
News flash: The Proteas have a new coach - Garrick Kirsten. :hehe:
@WK - I would not mind going out with only 6 on the score card!! :grk: :grk: :grk: :grk: :grk: :grk:
That would be considered a good score!!! :grk: :grk: :grk: :grk: :grk: :grk:
-
we'll call it street fishing, since apparantly they swim up the road make U-turn's and then head out for some cricket action. :hehe:
So the category will be S&CF fishing :hehe:
-
:hyst: :hyst:
-
:lolo:
-
now that deserves a mexican wave :win:
-
So the category will be S&CF fishing :hehe:
Exactly... Now we have to invest in some more fishing gear. But what? And do we now need a different permit as it's no longer salt water and it's not freshwater fishing. :cnfzd Maybe your driver's license is would be accepted as the fish is swimming on the road. Who would enforce the rules? MCM or the traffic department or SA sports? Way to :cnfzd :hehe: :hehe:
-
:hehe: (clap) :hyst:
-
It is immaterial where the fish was caught! What is clear is that the regulations state that it is illegal to catch garrick with a cast net - with or without a licence
So this young man is a criminal and should be prosecuted
-
Ziggy, you might be right and I respect your view on this. I am not starting a mud slinging contest but here is my view on this:
I think we should turn a blind eye in this case. The article did not state that he used a cast net "met ’n net aangekeer" and at least the fish was size. It was stuck in puddle and would have died anyway "is hy in die waterpoel op die krieketveld vasgekeer". At least he didn't sell the fish but fed his family unlike many other skelms who catch under-size Shad by the bucket load and run to their cars to hide it from the inspectors. You should see the photos of what the place looked like on Wednesday morning. The water was thigh high in the streets and I see this as a gift from God to a family that might have been in dire straits.
-
SAfish - being a lawyer - I look at things legalistically. Even a net is illegal, and no licence? And, when poor subsistence fishermen take illegal fish, or when people strip the rocks of mussels because they are hungry, or when the skelms take illegal fish - its all the same.....even if a family is in dire straits and takes illegal fish - thats a crime. Otherwise we could say that anyone in dire straits can burgle your house, steal your car etc etc because they are in need
That the garrick was going to die anyway is also irrelevant - not an argument that will succeeed legally. If a kudu is being stalked by a lion, can you shoot it (without a licence) because it was going to die anyway? So, in the extreme scenario, would murdering an old person be justified - because he was going to die anyway.
So not mudslinging - just extrapolating
-
I agree with you that what he did might have been illegal, but what if he had a license and used a landing net? The article states that he is an avid angler and I assume he has an angling licence. When I read the article I did not look at it from a legal point of view, only as an amazing story of something you don't see everyday. WK, J-Rock and myself were joking on another thread about being able to fish from my balcony because of the flooding and the next day it almost happened to this guy. :hehe:
I think I would have chased that fish also if I was in the same situation, however I would have tried to release it in the sea because I don't eat Garrick. This might have been a problem because half the town's roads were inaccessible.
-
I agree with you that what he did might have been illegal, but what if he had a license and used a landing net? The article states that he is an avid angler and I assume he has an angling licence.
the regulations state that Garrick can only be captured with a hook - so even if he had a licence and used a landing net, then he would have had to catch it on a hook to be legal
If he was convicted, then his sentencecould well be mitigated because of the extraordinary situation
Its all an interesting story though!