ULTIMATE ANGLING - the Ultimate SA Fishing website

General Angling Topics => Shore Angling => Topic started by: Xander on February 01, 2020, 09:47:08 PM

Title: Cracker Kob in Violence Central...
Post by: Xander on February 01, 2020, 09:47:08 PM
Check this beauty @ Macassar beach Friday Morning
Title: Re: Cracker Kob in Violence Central...
Post by: emjay on February 02, 2020, 07:12:00 AM
Monster! Do you have any further details on it?
Title: Re: Cracker Kob in Violence Central...
Post by: Xander on February 02, 2020, 09:22:33 AM
Nope just that the guys were going for Bronzies and got his one...
Title: Re: Cracker Kob in Violence Central...
Post by: Visenvryheid on February 02, 2020, 10:07:51 AM
Less big cob like that in SA than there are rhinos...Luckily the big ones I heard of coming out this week my side, one of 50kg or so, went back swimming and never even got removed from the water for a photo..
Title: Re: Cracker Kob in Violence Central...
Post by: colin on February 02, 2020, 10:21:15 AM
Less big cob like that in SA than there are rhinos.  :corrct: totally agree with Visvryheid . Any trophy fish like that should be returned. that fish probably lays more eggs than 100  60cm females .  :-( :toppie:
Title: Re: Cracker Kob in Violence Central...
Post by: Visenvryheid on February 03, 2020, 12:01:19 AM
Ja sorry good catch and all too, but we need to start taking more care of our breeding stock..The latest science estimated that less than 1000 individual jumbo female cobs were responsible for 90% of the coblets on our entire coast that we catch..A just size breeding cob releases a few thousand eggs once a year, a jumbo mama (50kg is between 20-30yrs old) may spawn multiple times a year, her eggs have a much higher survival rate than the younger females due to higher oil content, and she might release many millions of eggs each spawn event, which makes her breeding capacity the same potentially as many thousand younger just breeding size females (90cm -1m long and 5-8yrs old), not a hundred younger females! Ja boggles my mind..
Title: Re: Cracker Kob in Violence Central...
Post by: emjay on February 03, 2020, 07:09:12 AM
Ja sorry good catch and all too, but we need to start taking more care of our breeding stock..The latest science estimated that less than 1000 individual jumbo female cobs were responsible for 90% of the coblets on our entire coast that we catch..A just size breeding cob releases a few thousand eggs once a year, a jumbo mama (50kg is between 20-30yrs old) may spawn multiple times a year, her eggs have a much higher survival rate than the younger females due to higher oil content, and she might release many millions of eggs each spawn event, which makes her breeding capacity the same potentially as many thousand younger just breeding size females (90cm -1m long and 5-8yrs old), not a hundred younger females! Ja boggles my mind..


This is why "slot sizes" should be more of a thing like how they do it in the USA. Although I'm not sure how successful it will be in South Africa. We can't even get the greedy chops to let undersized fish go!
Title: Re: Cracker Kob in Violence Central...
Post by: Bigben on February 03, 2020, 10:27:47 AM
klomp suurgatte and envious...


When people are within their rights and the law why do you wana spoil the thread with your negativity..comparing Kob with Rhino stats..really now


No wonder people post less pics on all social formats..


 :envy
Title: Re: Cracker Kob in Violence Central...
Post by: RiyadhEd on February 03, 2020, 10:36:19 AM
WOW, what an awesome catch. I very seldomly take fish home. Also species dependant and how its hooked. Big fish gets returned, even in langebaan I return my catches. People think I am nuts, but I land alot of stumpnoses there on a good day.
Title: Re: Cracker Kob in Violence Central...
Post by: Kes on February 03, 2020, 12:48:25 PM
Just by looking at those pics, I'm assuming that that fish was not released..
Title: Re: Cracker Kob in Violence Central...
Post by: Bigben on February 03, 2020, 01:36:29 PM
Most conservation minded guy in that photo..Wikus van de Merwe....
Title: Re: Cracker Kob in Violence Central...
Post by: Visenvryheid on February 03, 2020, 08:34:06 PM
Sometimes the fish die, its like that..but suurgat not..bro ben you behind the times..latest research showed that there are probably less than a thousand of those big cob left..this was based on studying the genetics of the young cob up and down the coast, now then how many rhino are left? Way more than that..It is what it is, think about it for a second before you get upset..like you cant just go into the commons and shoot rhino anymore, but we can and kill fish that are way more rare than a cob or rhino, with that privilege comes responsibility.
And people don't post less because of others saying the fish should have been released, LOL not with the pics of lawns full of grunters and bottoms and cobs etc that I've seen, its because if you post a pic tomorrow the hoards decend and act like uncultured and irresponsible asses and ruin the good fishing for everyone..my mates post pics, but they make sure to wait a few weeks at least till the run of fish is over! Otherwise it ruins it for everyone else who is on it and not a wassap fisherman LOL
Title: Re: Cracker Kob in Violence Central...
Post by: Xander on February 03, 2020, 09:38:42 PM
Visenvryheid as far as I know this fish was released. I think all of us wish we were the old timers and could look after the stocks and not be so short sighted to take pictures of 20 dead 100 pounders. Those days are gone I will honestly punch someone who kill such a fish. That is who we are and I think I am talking for most of us... Visenvryheid you are right we all need to do better
Title: Re: Cracker Kob in Violence Central...
Post by: Lofty on February 04, 2020, 01:11:27 PM
Visenvryheid as far as I know this fish was released. I think all of us wish we were the old timers and could look after the stocks and not be so short sighted to take pictures of 20 dead 100 pounders. Those days are gone I will honestly punch someone who kill such a fish. That is who we are and I think I am talking for most of us... Visenvryheid you are right we all need to do better
I'm afraid not,saw this on Facebook..If I recall..On FB it said that unfortunately it was kept for ''Easter curry fish...'' or something to that efect..Yes,very good catch,but I agree with the conservation minded folk who posted,rather keep 1/2 smaller Kob to eat and let the big mommas go after taking a few good fotos to brag with... :win: Much more  :resp: for the anglers who release their big fish... :bow:
Title: Re: Cracker Kob in Violence Central...
Post by: Kes on February 04, 2020, 01:58:17 PM

Visenvryheid as far as I know this fish was released. I think all of us wish we were the old timers and could look after the stocks and not be so short sighted to take pictures of 20 dead 100 pounders. Those days are gone I will honestly punch someone who kill such a fish. That is who we are and I think I am talking for most of us... Visenvryheid you are right we all need to do better
I'm afraid not,saw this on Facebook..If I recall..On FB it said that unfortunately it was kept for ''Easter curry fish...'' or something to that efect..Yes,very good catch,but I agree with the conservation minded folk who posted,rather keep 1/2 smaller Kob to eat and let the big mommas go after taking a few good fotos to brag with... :win: Much more  :resp: for the anglers who release their big fish... :bow:


The ones over a meter don't taste great and have also reached sexual maturity at this size. Best to put them back.


 The best eating size is between 70cm and 80cm.





Title: Re: Cracker Kob in Violence Central...
Post by: Grumpy on February 04, 2020, 06:11:50 PM
Ja, I  kept and tried to eat a cob like that once. It was very course and really not that tasty.i endedup donating 80% to my staff in Durban. They probably curried it.


I love cob for supper, but only keep a smallie now and again. I prefer to send them back quietly.  I get much more pleasure out of that nowadays than killing them.


Peculiarly enough though I have been reading a lot on cob species , breeding and also the state of the stock.  I am concerned.  They are considered  collapsed.


As for this slot size , it only took  the US Striped bass about 15 years to recover from a collapsed state. The situation was very heavily policed and once the anglers saw the results they also bought into it.
I would warrant a guess that the USA fishery is probably the healthiest and best managed worldwide.  One just needs to fish there and also see the fish they land. Unbelievable!


Most of these fish end up in a fish shop sadly, but then can one blame the anglers?. R60/kg
Still  a good fish though, well done.
Title: Re: Cracker Kob in Violence Central...
Post by: forensic on February 04, 2020, 10:43:27 PM
Perhaps the anglers tried their level best to release that cob and it died on them?
Lifting a fish like that for a snapshot before trying to release it is certainly also a NO NO.
Shaun Mey's big cob pic is/was irresponsible as it is photo's like this that set a precedent for what is acceptable.
Killing a big cob when its common knowledge that their stock is running at less than 5% of what it should be, is what irks me.

If your family is starving go for it.

If that angler and his family/friends are not close to or below the breadline and if the fish didn't die whilst they tried to release it then the conclusion can only be that they are a POEPOL.

There are lots of them too.

The Cape Town rock and surf scene is highly populated, its like killing cob is cool!

Their population peaks again near PE.

There are way more assholes around than big cob.

DAFF, why no moratorium on this species? Wake up, popularity has never preserved a species!

So whats good in this case is that Big Ben recognizes the angler in the pic as Wikus van der Merve.  perhaps  Big Ben you could ask him for the details re that cob so we don't go barking up the wrong tree and can all still consider him as a conservationist.
 



Title: Re: Cracker Kob in Violence Central...
Post by: emjay on February 05, 2020, 08:43:41 AM
Ja, I  kept and tried to eat a cob like that once. It was very course and really not that tasty.i endedup donating 80% to my staff in Durban. They probably curried it.


I love cob for supper, but only keep a smallie now and again. I prefer to send them back quietly.  I get much more pleasure out of that nowadays than killing them.


Peculiarly enough though I have been reading a lot on cob species , breeding and also the state of the stock.  I am concerned.  They are considered  collapsed.


As for this slot size , it only took  the US Striped bass about 15 years to recover from a collapsed state. The situation was very heavily policed and once the anglers saw the results they also bought into it.
I would warrant a guess that the USA fishery is probably the healthiest and best managed worldwide.  One just needs to fish there and also see the fish they land. Unbelievable!


Most of these fish end up in a fish shop sadly, but then can one blame the anglers?. R60/kg
Still  a good fish though, well done.


Problem is we don't have enough policing. I was pleasantly surprised when I was checked for my license over the festive season. That was the first time in over three years that I was checked. I always compliment and thank the authorities when they check me, because I am genuinely happy to see them and for them to check me, but it needs to be more common practice
Title: Re: Cracker Kob in Violence Central...
Post by: Bigben on February 05, 2020, 09:14:18 AM
Perhaps the anglers tried their level best to release that cob and it died on them?
Lifting a fish like that for a snapshot before trying to release it is certainly also a NO NO.
Shaun Mey's big cob pic is/was irresponsible as it is photo's like this that set a precedent for what is acceptable.
Killing a big cob when its common knowledge that their stock is running at less than 5% of what it should be, is what irks me.

If your family is starving go for it.

If that angler and his family/friends are not close to or below the breadline and if the fish didn't die whilst they tried to release it then the conclusion can only be that they are a POEPOL.

There are lots of them too.

The Cape Town rock and surf scene is highly populated, its like killing cob is cool!

Their population peaks again near PE.

There are way more assholes around than big cob.

DAFF, why no moratorium on this species? Wake up, popularity has never preserved a species!

So whats good in this case is that Big Ben recognizes the angler in the pic as Wikus van der Merve.  perhaps  Big Ben you could ask him for the details re that cob so we don't go barking up the wrong tree and can all still consider him as a conservationist.


You are more than welcome to FB search Wikus or his business MMM Adventures and ask him. In this way you get the information from the horses mouth. You'll be pleasantly surprised I'm sure as to his mindset concerning fishing. I've learnt a lot from the gentleman over the years. But let me not advocate him...feel free to do your own investigation of what transpired with this kob.

Title: Re: Cracker Kob in Violence Central...
Post by: Visenvryheid on February 05, 2020, 11:12:19 AM
Sorry ous, I don't want to cause a s#itstorm..I actually just want to try improve things, only way to do it is with a little education along the way..
https://www.nda.agric.za/doaDev/sideMenu/fisheries/fisheriesresearch%20and%20development/docs/STATUS%20REPORT%202016.pdf (https://www.nda.agric.za/doaDev/sideMenu/fisheries/fisheriesresearch%20and%20development/docs/STATUS%20REPORT%202016.pdf)
Check out the 2016 status report on our fisheries, the latest I've been able to find. Some are in worse shape since then I can assure you, some are the same..same are a little improved. Nothing much has changed regulation wise..makes for interesting if depressing reading.

http://awsassets.wwf.org.za/downloads/wwf_a4_fish_facts_report_lr.pdf (http://awsassets.wwf.org.za/downloads/wwf_a4_fish_facts_report_lr.pdf)
There is the 2011 wwf one..68% of our fisheries technically collapsed, and I can guarantee you that there are commercials and recrommercials going out tonight to target species on that list, with no limit or no care in respective cases.. I've heard of longlines being set across rivers next to breede to target cob. Yesterday I saw the recromercials, and the commercial (who was bust last year or year before poaching tons of Red stumpnose out of eastern cape MPA's, and kicked out cape town for doing the same and perlies, but somehow just is left to carry on raping the ocean without licence being revoked?!)anyway they were all storming out to fill up on cob that are amassing on spawning aggregations outside river mouths right now, been on it last few days. Research/tagging has shown that those fish are resident even though they travel far to spawn and migrate back to waters outside their home river mouths post spawn and big mammas carry on spawning..anyway still to this day commercials and poachers (and those that are both) are still allowed freely to decimate spawning aggregations of species that are in critical shape, filling tons, right under the nose of the big red boat (fisheries) that is parked off the harbour for days doing nothing..And its their stocks they are stuffing with no regard, just move on after and do it somewhere else ,we not much better than the chinese, that is the state of affairs..geelbek, carpenters, silver and dusky cob are all collapsed and are all STILL the main target of line fisheries with NO limit and NO regulation or protection regarding targeting spawning masses of fishor large breeding stock, and these species are still actively targeted by the inshore hake trawl which is allowed to catch more bycatch, and sell it, than hake and is still somehow a SASSI green fishery..I've heard of longlines being set across rivers next to breede to target cob.
So a lot more rotten and bleak than one 100lb cob..but ja it starts with us..the same lawyers that have unfortunately opened up red steenbras have also protected fisheries all along the coast through advising DAFF about current policies, slot limits, MPA's etc and sure in the future they are coming, along with more MPA's and litigating against gas exploration/sonic cannons, which stuffed chokka and tuna on our eastern southern coast for years..there are studies confirming how it did the same in namibia completely shutting down the tuna fishery there..but ja the will to change things is there and it starts with us, and then educating our fellow fishermen and women as government is not going to do it for us..I completely buy into a new improved state of our fisheries!Anyways..

Big female cob over 100lb (breeding stock)- less than 1000 individuals..White and black rhino respectively, in SA, is estimated at 19000 and 4000 individuals of which some are breeding stock..So one can conservatively say that breeding cob are at least as rare as breeding stock of rhino in SA, and likely more rare..Now a rhino will calf from 7 years on apparently and a cob will be mature around the same age, they both live to be 50 years old but a rhino will make a calf a 2 1/2 years and a mature cob will spawn potentially millions of fry of which a small percentage will survive, once or more a year..They are similar in most respects except that and the only reason why we dont have millions of huge cob in our waters is human greed, there used to be millions of them. All around the world the same or similar species have been collapsed in a similar fashion and only in the states and a few other places has a concerted effort been made to bring them back. Sea trout, red and black drum and white sea bass are all similar species to our cob and bek and the fishing here should be like they have made it to be over there. The two biggest fish of the family, one occuring in bajas cortez sea and other off china, have both been collapsed and not returned, the biggest gets over a hundred kilo..random facts LOL..enjoy the day all..Ja I kept a cob for newyears and kept one last year too, but they were just right 5-8kg range and I did not feel to guilty..glad that when I heard of a big one being caught at the river mouth last week, 100lber, they never even took it out the water for a photo, water release..makes me think there is hope maybe..times may be changing.
Title: Re: Cracker Kob in Violence Central...
Post by: Lofty on February 05, 2020, 04:39:44 PM
I don't know ALL the details of this catch,but what I've read is that Wikus didn't catch the Kob,neither was the angler one of his clients on said day...seems he just helped the Oom with the pics...Perhaps he tried to convince the Oom to release to no avail...who knows.. :dunno:
As Visenvryheid said,some recromercials still set up nets in the bigger tidal rivers like Gourits and Kleinbrak rivers..found and retrieved nets and released trapped fish at Gouritz before,so it's not hearsay...Also seems everyone knew that a certain Mosselbay family had nets set up in Kleinbrak,catching mainly Grunter and Kob but nothing was really done about it... (bat
Title: Re: Cracker Kob in Violence Central...
Post by: Visenvryheid on February 05, 2020, 07:18:54 PM
Ja heard of that..long lines, gillnets..eish all the eyes are on breede but then no eyes are on next door and down the drag as well..and at sea a hake trawler is trying their best to find them, target them and catch them by mistake and right inshore the commercial line fleet are chasing then down where they mass to spawn every year..We just know the spots as cob marks as that where you find them and thats all you find there..deep cob marks, shallow cob marks..each year and less and the proportion snot cobs go up..all signs of a collapsed fishery, or one getting worse..one that is already considered long ago collapsed..So you'd think one 100lb'er doesn't make a difference but the species are under so much pressure than each large fish makes a huge difference..According to the research, every ten jumbos removed from the breeding pool would leave us with just under a percent less recruitment bass cobs up and down the coast..thats pretty scary. The genetic research also found stocks are resident but move and intermingle to spawn, as well silver and dusky are interbreeding and hybridizing as there are not enough duskies on the spawning grounds and there are clear signs of genetic bottlenecks in our population compared to japanese or auz stocks meaning few individuals are responsible for large proportions of babies and large sections of the genetic pool have been removed. Shame I still keep my occasional right sizer as said but thank goodness the big ones I hooked had the hooks pull and and..I dont want a fish like that to die on my accord. As my mate says those who go and poach the spawning aggregations nevermind the licenced poachers, they are not shunned in the small towns, they are not shunned at braais and the bar, and spar..there is a problem with society, imagine stacking some rhino horns on the wall above your bar at home and checking the reaction in a local community..But let someone poach or make a living off harvesting an endangered species in the sea and its totally cool, something is still off with south african society. In the states the stocks have been recovered so well that there is so much fish of good quality that if you want to be a recromercial you can get a licence to do so, in a very regulated fishery, on select species, within slot limits and during tightly controlled seasons outside of spawn time to stop targeting of the aggregations. Its so forward thinking and they have made an economy out the sea, we just talk about the economy of the sea while a few are allowed to rape it.Sorry bit of a rant but the truth and got nothing to do with the original post but ja the state of affairs, if we start being the change, then times will change..if we don't care the resource will be gone and i'll have to go find fish somewhere else to keep me sane in this mad world.
Title: Re: Cracker Kob in Violence Central...
Post by: Visenvryheid on February 05, 2020, 07:25:36 PM
Oh ja and now drones arrived..so hundreds of ous are getting onto fish they could never reach and ...have a debt of 20-30k or more for a drone to justify: "I have to sell fish to cover the cost", so just one more nail in the coffin..or not depends on us as we are those people..refering to the new wave of cape droners here more than anything else..heard the excuse for selling fish now a few times. it was bad enough when a few recromercial boaters target collapsed species to cover fuel and rent, but now there is a whole new can of worms..
Title: Re: Cracker Kob in Violence Central...
Post by: RiyadhEd on February 06, 2020, 09:57:12 AM
Damn, I caught a red steenbras once. It was less than a cm under size. The boat owner was so fussy with sizing and loosing his permit. The hook was halfway down the fish throat, but no, cant take it home. The fish died while trying to get the hook out.
Title: Re: Cracker Kob in Violence Central...
Post by: Visenvryheid on February 06, 2020, 11:04:13 AM
If the fish died on the hook and its a chunk of meat then my personal opinion is to not waste it..law says otherwise though..to eat that or let the sea eat it, as nothing goes to waste in the sea, both would be right depends on the angle you look at it from. The boat owner has more to loose, although the last time I saw anyone being checked was years back LOL. Our local special cases who are portrayed in the media as conservationists, wait for the upwell and then go park their boat funny enough painted grey like a poacher and go park off the pinnacles just outside the marine reserve and pot with spear as many juvenile red steenbras as their secret hatches can fill. I've seen pictures of lawns full..Up north each big one that gets kept in the ciskei/ transkei coast is a dent in the stock although they are on the slow increase and there are a fair amounts of adults again on the deep reefs where few can get to them and weather and current prevent them from being accessed most days so enough survive and thats why we are seeing younguns all the way down to false bay once again..
In reality the apartheid government stuffed up the stock proper when they allowed the foreign fleets to bottom trawl the agulhas banks to work around sanctions. The stock was already collapsed as a whole before that if you consider what it was a hundred years back when you'd catch anything from a tunny to a yellowtail to a geelbek throwing a mackerel off the rocks and the biggest issue of getting them out was getting them past the packs of 50kg red steenbras that were trying to rob you. There are tales of migrations to and from spawning grounds where the sea would turn red, a red tide of steenbras..there was a ship sunk off ystervarkfontein or somewhere blombos side back in the day that was containing chemicals or poisons and there was a tide of dead 100lb and bigger red steenbras that washed out in the days after..There are tales of shipwrecks off our coast in days past where the guys in the seas were attacked by packs of large red fish with teeth likes dogs, where with the fish and blood the sea would go red..We long way off there LOL
Title: Re: Cracker Kob in Violence Central...
Post by: Grumpy on February 10, 2020, 01:14:23 PM
This is a complex issue. It is  management of the commercial fishery right down to the average Joe on the beach. When one considers who is put in charge, it is understandable.  There are some very learned people in fisheries , thing is that they dont call the shots. Targeting the Recromercials will make a difference, but the clubs dont seen to have the desire or the teeth to actually do it.


Banning of all night ski-boat fishing would be a really good start. This has been bandied about quite a lot , but nothing seems to have  happened about it.


I was in southern Mozambique recently where after dark I  saw a fleet of what can only be assumed to be foreign vessels fishing.  Hell it looked like PE and St Francis in chokka season. That is in itself a problem
Every time I goto the Transkei I see vessels offshore that I am convinced dont belong there. Seen at night,  gone during the day. Often we fish quite far offshore as well and never see anything in daytime
We can only hope and wait to see what comes of it.
SimplePortal 2.3.7 © 2008-2026, SimplePortal