ULTIMATE ANGLING - the Ultimate SA Fishing website

General Angling Topics => Shore Angling => Topic started by: Marthin on September 17, 2010, 01:23:24 PM

Title: Group that wants to outlaw any form of R&S shark angling
Post by: Marthin on September 17, 2010, 01:23:24 PM
Guys please look below...

Reduce Shark Bag Limit - http://www.sharklife.co.za/ (http://www.sharklife.co.za/)
 Sharklife Conservation Group

Dear Minister of Environmental Affairs
Despite its relatively short coastline, South Africa has one of the world’s most diverse faunas of sharks. The region includes representatives from all 10 orders of cartilaginous fish encompassing over 181 (15%) of the 1,171 species listed worldwide, 79 of which are endemic to South Africa. Many of these species inhabit the inshore zone and are susceptible to catches by recreational fishermen, who are entitled to kill up to 10 sharks per day.
Recreational fisheries include shore and boat based anglers. Sharks are not normally targeted by recreational fishers, except in competitions for points or club records. Although the vast majority of sharks are returned alive to the sea after capture a minority of anglers will keep their catch for sale or deliberately kill sharks to reduce unwanted predation of hooked fish. These trends are increasing with sharply declining catches of popular line fish species as well as the improved market for shark meat.
The number of sharks caught in this fishery is poorly documented and the impact on shark stocks is unknown. Unlike bony fish, the biology and life-history traits (e.g., long-lived, late age at maturity, production of relatively few young) of sharks makes them inherently vulnerable to over-fishing. Often they are amongst the apex predators in complex food webs and their removal could have dire results for the ecosystem as a whole. These factors should elicit a precautionary management response, yet despite repeated calls for improved conservation and management, the response has been slow and piecemeal.
Best practice approaches to shark conservation and management will vary widely because of the diversity of species, life history styles and habitat use. Conservation strategies can also be hard to implement due to the conflicting interests of user groups (i.e. fishermen and divers) and a lack of compliance. A simple solution to these problems is an amendment of the current recreational bag limit for sharks from 1 to 0. This approach has numerous advantages over other management strategies:

      It is simple It covers the entire South African coast It covers all chondrichthyan species It covers all habitats It is effective for endemics as well as migratory species. It has a good chance of receiving support and hence compliance from recreational fishers. Simple to enforce and prosecute transgressors

Sharklife and its supporters urge the South African government to prioritize this proposal as a matter of urgency. Sharks are critical components of the marine ecosystem and as such require relatively adequate protection.

  Petition Supporters:
1 Sharklife Smith Grant 16 September 2010 Johannesburg
2 Costa Filipa 16 September 2010 Pemba
3 Bakker Judith 16 September 2010 Amsterdam
4 Brown Nicole 16 September 2010 Cape Town
5 Greeff Lee-anne 16 September 2010
6 Woest Jaco 16 September 2010
7 Endres Neil 16 September 2010
8 Hulse Philip 16 September 2010 Sandton
9 Global Shark Initiative Vandevelde Katrien 16 September 2010 Nieuwrode
10 Sigg Marcel 16 September 2010 Johannesburg
11 K C 16 September 2010
12 Wouters Jan 16 September 2010 Nieuwrode
13 Welch Graham Welch 16 September 2010 Johannesburg
14 Africa Experts Holthuysen Michael 16 September 2010 Durban
15 Correll Nancy 16 September 2010 Dover
16 Duchamps Karin 16 September 2010 Kessel-Lo
17 van Rensburg Johan 16 September 2010 Johannesburg
18 Dillman Peter 16 September 2010 Las Vegas NV
19 Wouters Kiran 16 September 2010 Nieuwrode
20 Wouters Kiran 16 September 2010 Nieuwrode
Page 1 of 8
Title: Re: Group that wants to outlaw any form of R&S shark angling
Post by: steve m on September 17, 2010, 04:52:34 PM
Just how much do you guys think that this person knows about shark fishing?

"are susceptible to catches by recreational fishermen, who are entitled to kill up to 10 sharks per day"- How often do you catch 10 differant species of sharks in a day? and how many people would keep them all?


"Although the vast majority of sharks are returned alive to the sea after capture a minority of anglers will keep their catch for sale"-This is illegal so how will makeing a new law help?

"These trends are increasing with sharply declining catches of popular line fish species as well as the improved market for shark meat."- I would have said that more people release sharks now days than before? with wpsaa going as far as to ban the use of sharks and flatfish as bait!
i dont see how this makesense but whatever i fish for cob with half a yellowtail on 200lb steel with a 16/0 circle and sliding with my tn40 lol
Title: Re: Group that wants to outlaw any form of R&S shark angling
Post by: Marthin on September 17, 2010, 05:49:08 PM
steve you guys that have been doing this for long could probably give him more information but base it on facts.  Myself and JB2 have been mailing him today i'll post some of the conversations monday when i'm at the office again.

Basically they chose recreational fishing because of their limited resources etc... basically coming down to they feel Recreational fishers will be the best or easiest target because we do not stand together on a point.  Well i informed him that the honourable minister of forrest affairs and such made the same mistake earlier this year with the 200% increase in permit idea that ended up being 10% after anglers stood together...

But an ear will be kept to the ground.
Title: Re: Group that wants to outlaw any form of R&S shark angling
Post by: WalkersKiller on September 20, 2010, 04:47:53 PM
Please keep us posted Marthin!
Title: Re: Group that wants to outlaw any form of R&S shark angling
Post by: Marthin on September 21, 2010, 10:25:47 AM
Ok so far at least these guys are willing to listen.  They understand that there is a problem once you have put a fish on a restricted list, as you can now not target them intentionally even if you plan to release them.

They have asked for assistance from the legal aspect.  They basically do not want sharks killed by recreationals.  The main problem is the "slagters" who catch and illegally sell.
Title: Re: Group that wants to outlaw any form of R&S shark angling
Post by: Marthin on September 21, 2010, 10:54:13 AM
Hi there here is the latest.  Seems positive.

Hi Marthin,
 
Thanks for the input, I apologies if the our proposal, at first glance, appears to pigeon hole all R&S fishermen as thoughtless killers. Dr Matt Dicken is an avid fisherman himself and as such understands the industry very well. It was with this understanding that we sought to find a workable solution to the inadequate protection afforded sharks in the MLRA. What we are calling for is a change in the current regulations and are hoping to engage with all user groups to refine the mechanisms needed to affect such change.
 
I hope our communications have provided the catalyst to begin this process.
 
Kind regards
Title: Re: Group that wants to outlaw any form of R&S shark angling
Post by: LUPO on September 21, 2010, 10:59:08 AM
 :resp: MARTHIN - keep up the good work and please keep us informed.
Title: Re: Group that wants to outlaw any form of R&S shark angling
Post by: WalkersKiller on September 21, 2010, 02:30:04 PM
Hi Marthin, it would be ashamed if it was completely banned. I have a fishing mailing list with close to 1000 members and I get all sorts of emails. A lot of recreational fisherman kill sharks when they catch them as they regards them as a pest when they are targeting pignose and kob, I try and spread awareness as much as I can. I was talking to someone the other day who said he kills the occasional shark and chucks it back into the water, being as p*ssed off as I was I told him that there is a problem with the stocks of sharks, he thought it was acceptable because "There are so many of them" some sort of awareness does need to be brought to the recreational angler as very few know that sharks are highly endangered! And on the other hand I have got emails from England, Portugal and Holland asking me advice and best spots as they are coming to South Africa to enjoy catching and releasing a Shark from the shore... Just thought I would mention that, don't know if any of it is of any use!

WK
SimplePortal 2.3.7 © 2008-2026, SimplePortal