ULTIMATE ANGLING - the Ultimate SA Fishing website
General Angling Topics => Shore Angling => Topic started by: CASTSA on January 13, 2013, 10:38:34 AM
-
Hi UA,
Compliments to you all....hope this year brings you all good health, good fishing and good wealth!!!!
I was very shocked the other day when we were filming on the South coast of KZN to see guys actually STILL gaffing fish??
I wanted to ask you all, IS THIS STILL A PRACTISED THING?? I thought all gaffing was banned??
Anyway, I was totally blown away when I saw guys gaffing a poor Brown skate after it had already beached itself in the surf....and what amazed me more, was that they were not the only ones that had Gaffs, there was about 4 of them on the rocks??
Have we now, with the crazy pressure of competitive angling and we all have to be the best of the best, have we now gone backwards and brought this back to our fishing ways??
Very disturbed at the moment :dunno:
-
Hey Wes I have also been completely amazed at the times some people will gaff a fish! I've seen people unhook a fish and have a big wave sweep through and wash the diamond back into the water only to have the guy start bashing its back with the gaff to try and pull it back up for his photo duh I think that there may be times and places where a well placed gaff can save damage to the fish and angler. These times and places are VERY rare though! If there is a a beach or gulley nearby then spend the extra 5minutes to walk there and land the fish safely
-
Yes, i will gaff a fish that i'm taking home for the pot... I dont see a problem with that? :dunno:
Gaffing a non-ed is a different story... Almost as bad as dragging a non-ed onto the rocks like we often see in some SA fishing shows. swr
-
Wesley thanks for raising this matter. I have also seen these despicable instruments with some "anglers" and quite frankly never saw any reason why it should be used especially with non-edibles. :unhap
I would suggest that we appeal to all outlets selling them to refrain or anglers who are serious about conservation to boycott these stores.
-
Shaun I think Wes was only referring to shore angling for non eds. I doubt anyone has a problem with gaffing a fish for the pot
-
Wes you are right... I am a boat man and whilst have two gaffs on board they don't come out even for edibles if I can help it, but the use of them on non eds is deplorable and if we dont point it out to these people we are as guilty even it they tell us to bugger off at least it will make them think about it!
I watched BXLR(Antigua) marlin relase program on ESPN this monring with Norman Isaacs and was appaled to watch a crew member catch a non target species fish and the toss it 20-30 feet (cartwheeling into the sea)... there is no point to catch and relase of dead or damaged fish - where is the conservation in that? They only become vunerable to predation if injured.
I find my heavy gaff really usefull for coming alongside the jetty as a boat hook!
7/10
-
...was appaled to watch a crew member catch a non target species fish and the toss it 20-30 feet (cartwheeling into the sea)...
Sort of like this bloke did with a juvenile Hammer at Macs... not :clwn
(http://i819.photobucket.com/albums/zz111/Nellis_T/Macs/Ham1_zps37820620.jpg)
(http://i819.photobucket.com/albums/zz111/Nellis_T/Macs/Ham2_zps4eb1dc57.jpg)
-
Thanks for mentioning this Castra.
Gaffing has never been big on my agenda , and I tend to stay away from areas ,where fish is hard to land , lots of guys hide behind this ,to go down with long long gaffs a few of them in Overberg.
I might step on some toes here , these lipgrippers I thought was a great idea , the thing is [some of the has got a scale , and you have to let a fish dangle from mostly his bottomlip IMO I think this can do just as much damageas gaffing]
Gaffing is dead from the Shore for me , I do think it has a important role for the offshore guys in some cases .
I think the bunch of us that knows must try ,to help these uninformed guys , Its really about not knowing better .
One would imagine , if your fishing next to guys gaffing ,maybe call them over when you , or your buddy is ON , tell them politily 'leave the gaff guys , I want to show you this , is how we do it ', and share you tips with him , I am sure you will be able to swing his head in a positive manner!
-
Gaffing was banned on the North Coast by the Union guys. And this was done because of the flatfish. If you fishing of the beach their is really no need to use a gaff.
-
I haven't seen a fish gaffed off the beach for years, I thought this practice was dead and buried :unhap
-
Thanks for the reply guys, I was only referring to non-eds off the beach and fish we want to release, not the winners of the pot tour!! :happ:
It really does amaze me, and I know it was banned on the North Coast union but not on the south coast league?? WHY?
Yes, in some cases pulling a fish over the rocks is harmful I agree with that although you do not damage vital organs and the fish has a much better chance of survival.
I worry about competitive angling if we are more focused on point than the safety of our fish.......sad to say it, that really is going backwards!
-
yip it seems there is still a lot of work to be done here as far as conservation and release techniques are involved!! Marlin are still getting slaughtered and fish getting abused of the rocks , and gaffs getting used on beaches :-(
In defense of south african anglers, this crap is happening all over the world, some of the worst fish, shark abuse I ever saw was in the US.
-
Whats a gaff.... ?? :cnfzd .
-
This is a very sensative issue, there are pro on both sides and cons on both sides, maybe to play devils advocate, is it fair to the fish to not gaff and they are getting smashed on the rocks where as a well placed gaff you could pull the fish out of the impcat zone. However a bad placed gaff could result in punched internal organs. There are two sides but to have a boycott on all sdtores that sell gafs is very short sighted, with this mentality we should boycot all toyota dealers as they sell quantams which become taxis and taxis are a law unto themself on the roads. I know many tackle shop owners and they are the biggest consovasionist i know as their buisness is dependant on return customers who are catching fish.
-
Jordz you do have valid points and yes it is true that the use of a gaff is a very sensitive issue. I am by no means an expert angler but do read a lot of literature and watch TV and video presentations of our fantastic sport. Worth to mention is the fact that you would hardly ever (if ever) see the use of a gaff in these programs. This observation tells me that the gaff is not essential
I think it is not difficult to make a gaff, therefore, if you do want to use it then make it. I do realize that some anglers gaff a fish meant for the pot and do not have a problem with it. My comment on boycotting the stores selling them is maybe a bit small sited but I do feel that if they sell them it makes it easy to obtain them and may inadvertently encourage the use of it. My 2c
-
My 2 Cents, And Questions, due to the fact that I have been a Fresh water Angler all my life, landing fish with landing nets are the only way I have known. But at one point I was told that landing nets on offshore boats are not legal. Is this true or not, am I allowed using a landing net on my offshore boat instead of a gaff. Then my 2 cents, due to the fact that I am a vaalie, my father tough me fishing from the beach, because of the possibility of losing line, sinkers and hooks, and not to even mention fish. And even though I am always tempted to fish off the rocks, after I lose my first sinker I move back to the beach, unless I am fishing slides or for shad. And before you all slaughter me; I know some of the better fishing happens on the rock. But at the same time, my personal best and most adored species have been caught off the beach at Vidal – my SilverTip Shark – Does the name ring a BELL? And that was done, man alone 20:30 at night with no gaff and a safe return/release. Currently I have tagged two beautiful Hammerheads from SilverTip, with the bite marks on the centre consol pillow as proof, and have safely returned/released another 4 hammerheads and one black tip no gaff (which was half the length of SilverTip). BIG QUESTION, Why??? I love shark, I play on their midfield they are going to eat my bait and even my hooked fish; it’s the way the dominos fall. THE ANSWER!!! I tag my sharks caught and release them back to Mother Nature to give me another truly exhausting fight, I fight my edible hard and land them or free spool them so to keep them from harm when the Jonnies are around. And even when I am offshore, would prefer not to use a gaff. Please let me know about the landing net, whether legal or not. w;k
-
sensitive subject
-
sensitive subject
-
im referring to bronzies here...
flatfish on a beach different story.
What the diffs, both fish has limited life once hooked, but stick to the rule, work the fish harder for a quicker landing, cut the trace if you can’t return the hook and try not to keep the fish out the water for more than 2 min. and as a skipper, I know how short 3 min can be, not to mention 2 min. but then I have to agree with you if you don’t want to hurt the fish, don’t fish. But at least do your best to get it back in the water without doing it unnecessary harm. Protect what we have, because it all we have!!!
-
im referring to bronzies here...
flatfish on a beach different story.
What the diffs, both fish has limited life once hooked, but stick to the rule, work the fish harder for a quicker landing, cut the trace if you can’t return the hook and try not to keep the fish out the water for more than 2 min. and as a skipper, I know how short 3 min can be, not to mention 2 min. but then I have to agree with you if you don’t want to hurt the fish, don’t fish. But at least do your best to get it back in the water without doing it unnecessary harm. Protect what we have, because it all we have!!!
100%
-
im referring to bronzies here...
flatfish on a beach different story.
What the diffs, both fish has limited life once hooked, but stick to the rule, work the fish harder for a quicker landing, cut the trace if you can’t return the hook and try not to keep the fish out the water for more than 2 min. and as a skipper, I know how short 3 min can be, not to mention 2 min. but then I have to agree with you if you don’t want to hurt the fish, don’t fish. But at least do your best to get it back in the water without doing it unnecessary harm. Protect what we have, because it all we have!!!
100%
:udman:
-
There is no point in gaffing a flat fish as this would cause tremendious damage to the fish, sharks again sensative, definatly not ooff the beach as you can just straight stick the fish right onto the sand and if anything use a rope around the tail to help you again this is a sensative subject (rope on the tail) for me the answer is that there are no two situations that are the same and the angler has to use his judgement in each case as weather to gaff or not
-
There is no point in gaffing a flat fish as this would cause tremendious damage to the fish, sharks again sensative, definatly not ooff the beach as you can just straight stick the fish right onto the sand and if anything use a rope around the tail to help you again this is a sensative subject (rope on the tail) for me the answer is that there are no two situations that are the same and the angler has to use his judgement in each case as weather to gaff or not
cool, thanks for the tip
-
using a gaff on the beach is rather stupid.... the only time i gaffed eva was in a dangerous situation on a very hectic rocky place. sharks only. and that was a very long tym ago.
-
this fish was gaffed...in the correct place.... fish was stuck behind the lip..... one hour later and the fish would have been dead...
can you see any marks?
-
i have to say reading this, that the only people on this thread that i've seen against gaffs are people that don't fish the southern and western cape.
Fish the falsbay rips/lips/dropoffs with 100kg bronzies not raggies, where you have to pull a fish out of 2m water onto 15cm of water.....
A well placed gaff made my bronzie fight at least another hour shorter, and ask someone like definition what happened without a gaff to him at macs. And with gaff we are not talking a meathook u could use to string up an elephant. The hook in my bronzie's mouth was bigger than the gaff it had behind it's dorsal!
-
I don't think its fair to say that everyone against the gaff has no idea of pulling big fish in difficult conditions. Mazeppa has seen many bronzies blackfins etc landed off the island that's 6 to 7 meters deep straight onto the ledge. Easy? No! Possible? Definitely! I'm the furthest thing from a big strong guy and I managed it :dunno: the normal argument is that yes an experienced angler can do it but not a novice. Well I don't know too many novices who know how to gaff a big fish safely. As I said before there are places and situations where a gaff may be better but those situations are few and far between
-
Seen a lot of non eds come out of a lot of places a long the coast, dont agree with gaffing, never have, never will, but I think the main thing here is people who gaff should know how to and where to stick a gaff, some of the best spots along the Western Cape shores, the high rocky points, I reckon it would be tough to land a 30kg Bronzie at some of those spots! I know a lot of EC SASAA ex SASAA guys use gaffs on the beach, especially with big bags, because when they get into shallow water, they either come in, or they sit and you either need to put huge strain on the fish to get it in, or as Ray says, gaff it in the right area so the fish can be released as quickly as possible, instead of tiring the fish out further.
-
I don't think its fair to say that everyone against the gaff has no idea of pulling big fish in difficult conditions. Mazeppa has seen many bronzies blackfins etc landed off the island that's 6 to 7 meters deep straight onto the ledge. Easy? No! Possible? Definitely! I'm the furthest thing from a big strong guy and I managed it :dunno: the normal argument is that yes an experienced angler can do it but not a novice. Well I don't know too many novices who know how to gaff a big fish safely. As I said before there are places and situations where a gaff may be better but those situations are few and far between
Good post Bradley !
-
try landing a 100kg blackray off gordonbay mountain with only pure love and no gaff...
-
Thanks for all the comments, really not trying to make a fuss here...just actually couldn't believe people still gaff.
I do feel strongly against gaffing as we also get giant fish up here in KZN (as do the rest of the country), huge flat fish, giant sandies, blackfins, zambies and more with a diversity of beach and point structures, deep lips, drop offs, and and and and....so respectfully I dont believe that this is a good enough reason to gaff...anyway....
Sometimes we have to look at what we do, and I personally have supported the non gaffing culture because of the fact that we are going in the right direction so to be honest, maybe we shouldn't fish where we cant get fish out without a gaff....
2c.......
-
sorry to say only the more competent anglers have some sort of idea how to gaff (still not 100% safe) and unfortunately those competent anglers lead from the front for beginners to follow through education and if beginners see anglers gaffing, be sure they will be in the shops buying a gaff for the next Bronzie day on the beach...
And this case that I mentioned was a seasoned angler with a beginner, where the beginner was stabbing at the fish while the seasoned angler just supported it!!...
anyway................
-
Thanks for all the comments, really not trying to make a fuss here...just actually couldn't believe people still gaff.
I do feel strongly against gaffing as we also get giant fish up here in KZN (as do the rest of the country), huge flat fish, giant sandies, blackfins, zambies and more with a diversity of beach and point structures, deep lips, drop offs, and and and and....so respectfully I dont believe that this is a good enough reason to gaff...anyway....
Sometimes we have to look at what we do, and I personally have supported the non gaffing culture because of the fact that we are going in the right direction so to be honest, maybe we shouldn't fish where we cant get fish out without a gaff....
2c.......
I totaly agree with you regarding dont fish where you cant land the fish, hence the reason i was taught to fish from the beach or next to the rocks. but at the same time, i dont know what the rest of the coutry looks like so i dont know where the other guys fish, or what their surroundings looks like.
-
Thanks for all the comments, really not trying to make a fuss here...just actually couldn't believe people still gaff.
I do feel strongly against gaffing as we also get giant fish up here in KZN (as do the rest of the country), huge flat fish, giant sandies, blackfins, zambies and more with a diversity of beach and point structures, deep lips, drop offs, and and and and....so respectfully I dont believe that this is a good enough reason to gaff...anyway....
Sometimes we have to look at what we do, and I personally have supported the non gaffing culture because of the fact that we are going in the right direction so to be honest, maybe we shouldn't fish where we cant get fish out without a gaff....
2c.......
... Or if it means dragging a fish across the rocks - yet to see a bare-footed angler on any SA fishing show drag a fish up onto the rocks.
My 2c... Nothing personal either, ultimately a lot relies on the experience and ethics of the angler, and the knowledge/actions they impart to others.
-
Hi Shaun,
I'm sorry bud, you still drag a fish up the rocks when it is gaffed..with or without a lethal point in its vitals, a few scratches, the fish can live with, especially Raggies as they hunt in the rocky areas for things like Galjoen and Blacktail. If you watch the show, the fish swim back ALIVE with NO vital damage done. So respectfully, we take really good care of the fish, no matter where we are, edible or NON EDS. That comment was not positive.
Look I know this is a touchy subject, but we do so much for our FISHING FOR THE FUTURE progress and to have anglers gaffing fish just seems to be going backwards to me.
That's the last I will comment on this, everyone has their own opinions and for those who carry a gaff, I hope you take an extra 10,20,30,40 minutes to get your fish out than stick that gaff into it, that's angling! and getting fish out without a gaff should be part of the sport ;-)
-
Good points Wes (clap)
-
Hi Shaun,
I'm sorry bud, you still drag a fish up the rocks when it is gaffed..with or without a lethal point in its vitals, a few scratches, the fish can live with, especially Raggies as they hunt in the rocky areas for things like Galjoen and Blacktail. If you watch the show, the fish swim back ALIVE with NO vital damage done. So respectfully, we take really good care of the fish, no matter where we are, edible or NON EDS. That comment was not positive.
Look I know this is a touchy subject, but we do so much for our FISHING FOR THE FUTURE progress and to have anglers gaffing fish just seems to be going backwards to me.
That's the last I will comment on this, everyone has their own opinions and for those who carry a gaff, I hope you take an extra 10,20,30,40 minutes to get your fish out than stick that gaff into it, that's angling! and getting fish out without a gaff should be part of the sport ;-)
Wes,
You're missing my point. I'm not a rock and surf angler, i fish from a boat - but if i did i personally wouldnt use a gaff. My comments should not be seen as negative either, it's my opinion.
Your concern (as is mine) is the treatment of a fish once caught, and the importance of getting it back in the water in the best condition possible. Perhaps the damage to a fish getting pulled up the rocks is less than a poorly gaffed fish, perhaps the damage is more than a well-placed gaff - each situation is different.
We should be taking a holistic view of the handling/landing of fish, rather than singling out one particular method. I'm all for FISHING FOR THE FUTURE, i have a 6 year-old son who lives for fishing.
Tight lines...
-
Mmmm. Thought something got lost in translation between Shaun and Wesley. Shot for clearing that up Shaun.
This December I saw a group on the beach - Dad and a couple of kids and friends all around 14 - 16 years old.
There was a good run of diamonds and with every hookup we saw dad rush down to the water with the gaff in hand, gaff the flattie and drag it up the beach no matter its size. Same thing on the return trip.
-
Hi Shaun,
Got your point 100%,
Thanks for your opinion, its always good to have them all.
I just got damn heart sore when I saw a gaff being used so disrespectfully on the beach by anglers, it just made me feel like the past 10 years of angling education and progression has been pointless.
But I'm sure we have many anglers that have dropped-the-gaff.............
Thanks guys
-
Hi guys
I know theire are lot of anglers out theire that fish , lot of new people to the sport and lot of experience guys , In SASAA events like nationals and a lot off the unions lot off big fish has been landed with out the use off a gaff , u just have to work the fish to an area were u can land it safely , yess theire are areas wheire u don't have a choice to gaff a fish butt in order to land it safely u have too in order to safe a fishes life and not tiring it out completely , in the last four years we landed lot off big fish without gaffs at our leagues !! in the competitive seen we try and fish for the future and promote it