ULTIMATE ANGLING - the Ultimate SA Fishing website

General Angling Topics => Shore Angling => Topic started by: ajaffer on November 27, 2012, 09:39:17 PM

Title: Advise on which is better- Daiwa Saltiga LD50/ Daiwa Saltiga 50HKP/ Penn Trq40g2
Post by: ajaffer on November 27, 2012, 09:39:17 PM
I'm in market for a reel.  I have no experience with a multiplier but i want something that will last.  Its got to have raw power and i am leaning towards the LD50. I have seen the reviews and it pulls like a tow truck.  I cant cast with a multiplier so i will learn to get the distance i need.  i have ruled out the Trinidad 30 already (brand preference i guess).  Andwhat would I put on the reel?  Thinking of 50lb backing braid(600m) with 200m 40lb mono and 30m of leader. 

Any thoughts? :dwa: :penn: :penn: :mp:
Title: Re: Advise on which is better- Daiwa Saltiga LD50/ Daiwa Saltiga 50HKP/ Penn Trq40g2
Post by: bryant on November 27, 2012, 09:45:53 PM
Just bought a lever drag 50 saltiga, throws a mile, but no cast control knob on the side, so takes some practice... got 600m 50 ib hmp and 150m xx .52topshot.....     all in all a solid reel...
Title: Re: Advise on which is better- Daiwa Saltiga LD50/ Daiwa Saltiga 50HKP/ Penn Trq40g2
Post by: Fritz on November 27, 2012, 10:17:25 PM
Eish! I can see a big bacha comming here. Stay away from the lever drag for now.
Go speak to the guys at Kingfisher and ask them to get 200m of .55  and then fill up with braid. You will probibly get about 500m. You leader should be about 8m. Or better yet . If the rod is standing next to your tackle box on the beach, you should have three turns of leader on the reel and the end of the leader should be just above your reel.
Title: Re: Advise on which is better- Daiwa Saltiga LD50/ Daiwa Saltiga 50HKP/ Penn Trq40g2
Post by: REEFMAN on November 28, 2012, 06:20:33 AM
Just bought a lever drag 50 saltiga, throws a mile, but no cast control knob on the side, so takes some practice... got 600m 50 ib hmp and 150m xx .52topshot.....     all in all a solid reel...

Huh? Use the preset Drag knob as a Cast control knob. Works exactly the same way... unless you've got the 2-speed Saltiga, not the Hyperspeed?

Fritz is right... stay away from the LD as a beginner's reel. Not the right reel to learn to cast with. Same goes for any free floating shaft reel... Torque/Fathom. The HKP is the one to go for out of your list.
Title: Re: Advise on which is better- Daiwa Saltiga LD50/ Daiwa Saltiga 50HKP/ Penn Trq40g2
Post by: ajaffer on November 29, 2012, 07:25:41 PM
Howsit guys.

I have thrown a multiplier on a 10 ft rod about 2 yrs ago and with some practise got it right after a few fumbles.  So I'll learn to do it on this one even if it takes a while.  What I was looking for was comparison of the reels in terms of power, casting ability ratio and overall capability.  Bare in mind the price of the Ld50 hs is R4000.  If you think I should expand, y search let me know also but please provide reasoning as well.

Thanks
Title: Re: Advise on which is better- Daiwa Saltiga LD50/ Daiwa Saltiga 50HKP/ Penn Trq40g2
Post by: REEFMAN on November 30, 2012, 11:35:25 AM
Jaffer... the Saltiga Lever Drag and the Penn Torque/Fathom are not "ordinary" multipliers - they work on a free floating spool shaft, which makes them difficult to cast even for seasoned anglers.
For pulling power, they are all much of a muchness, having drags that will seldom, if ever, get used to the max.
The Penn Trq has double dog pawls, making it's anti-reverse system much better than any Daiwa. Whether this will be a factor is a subject for conjecture. If you're continually catching 100kg + sharks, then it is certainly something to consider.
But the Penn Trq comes without a Centrifugal braking system, which doesn't help the castability, making it probably the most difficult multiplier I know to control in the cast.

Weighing all these things up, as I said earlier, out of the list you have chosen, the Saltiga HKP is the one to go for.
Title: Re: Advise on which is better- Daiwa Saltiga LD50/ Daiwa Saltiga 50HKP/ Penn Trq40g2
Post by: Weedeater on November 30, 2012, 01:12:47 PM
Jaffer... the Saltiga Lever Drag and the Penn Torque/Fathom are not "ordinary" multipliers - they work on a free floating spool shaft, which makes them difficult to cast even for seasoned anglers.
For pulling power, they are all much of a muchness, having drags that will seldom, if ever, get used to the max.
The Penn Trq has double dog pawls and an elongated Anti-reverse bearing, making it's anti-reverse system much better than any Daiwa. Whether this will be a factor is a subject for conjecture. If you're continually catching 100kg + sharks, then it is certainly something to consider.
But the Penn Trq comes without a Centrifugal braking system, which doesn't help the castability, making it probably the most difficult multiplier I know to control in the cast.

Weighing all these things up, as I said earlier, out of the list you have chosen, the Saltiga HKP is the one to go for.


Tony is right. I recently bought myself a LD50 and even though I've been casting with a multiplier for years, I battled initially until I figured out the reel works (i.e. cast control knob is same as drag knob). Took me 2 days at Kosi to get my casting up to scratch. If it were my money, I'd go for the Saltiga 50HKP (Gold spool).
Title: Re: Advise on which is better- Daiwa Saltiga LD50/ Daiwa Saltiga 50HKP/ Penn Trq40g2
Post by: Fritz on November 30, 2012, 01:30:54 PM
Jaffer... the Saltiga Lever Drag and the Penn Torque/Fathom are not "ordinary" multipliers - they work on a free floating spool shaft, which makes them difficult to cast even for seasoned anglers.
For pulling power, they are all much of a muchness, having drags that will seldom, if ever, get used to the max.
The Penn Trq has double dog pawls and an elongated Anti-reverse bearing, making it's anti-reverse system much better than any Daiwa. Whether this will be a factor is a subject for conjecture. If you're continually catching 100kg + sharks, then it is certainly something to consider.
But the Penn Trq comes without a Centrifugal braking system, which doesn't help the castability, making it probably the most difficult multiplier I know to control in the cast.

Weighing all these things up, as I said earlier, out of the list you have chosen, the Saltiga HKP is the one to go for.


Tony is right. I recently bought myself a LD50 and even though I've been casting with a multiplier for years, I battled initially until I figured out the reel works (i.e. cast control knob is same as drag knob). Took me 2 days at Kosi to get my casting up to scratch. If it were my money, I'd go for the Saltiga 50HKP (Gold spool).

In fact their is one at Kings on sale now for a steel.
Title: Re: Advise on which is better- Daiwa Saltiga LD50/ Daiwa Saltiga 50HKP/ Penn Trq40g2
Post by: skip on November 30, 2012, 01:38:39 PM
May i ask why not a good old SL50SH / Grandwave / or even the Saltist in the 50 size?
 
These reels are much cheaper and are up to the task - we have caught some big kingies on the infamous rocks of Goathill in Tofo, as well as some big Jonnies off the beach, all with the SL50SH. If you really want you can upgrade the drag washers to the carbontex ones - super smooth.
 
Just my 2CW.
Title: Re: Advise on which is better- Daiwa Saltiga LD50/ Daiwa Saltiga 50HKP/ Penn Trq40g2
Post by: Weedeater on November 30, 2012, 01:39:33 PM
Jaffer... the Saltiga Lever Drag and the Penn Torque/Fathom are not "ordinary" multipliers - they work on a free floating spool shaft, which makes them difficult to cast even for seasoned anglers.
For pulling power, they are all much of a muchness, having drags that will seldom, if ever, get used to the max.
The Penn Trq has double dog pawls and an elongated Anti-reverse bearing, making it's anti-reverse system much better than any Daiwa. Whether this will be a factor is a subject for conjecture. If you're continually catching 100kg + sharks, then it is certainly something to consider.
But the Penn Trq comes without a Centrifugal braking system, which doesn't help the castability, making it probably the most difficult multiplier I know to control in the cast.

Weighing all these things up, as I said earlier, out of the list you have chosen, the Saltiga HKP is the one to go for.


Tony is right. I recently bought myself a LD50 and even though I've been casting with a multiplier for years, I battled initially until I figured out the reel works (i.e. cast control knob is same as drag knob). Took me 2 days at Kosi to get my casting up to scratch. If it were my money, I'd go for the Saltiga 50HKP (Gold spool).

In fact their is one at Kings on sale now for a steel.


How much Fritz?
Title: Re: Advise on which is better- Daiwa Saltiga LD50/ Daiwa Saltiga 50HKP/ Penn Trq40g2
Post by: REEFMAN on November 30, 2012, 01:40:20 PM
May i ask why not a good old SL50SH / Grandwave / or even the Saltist in the 50 size?
 
These   reels are much cheaper and are up to the task - we have caught some big   kingies on the infamous rocks of Goathill in Tofo, as well as some big   Jonnies off the beach, all with the SL50SH. If you really want you can   upgrade the drag washers to the carbontex ones - super smooth.
 
Just my 2CW.
Those are certainly options... I was only commenting on the list he gave... Daiwa Saltiga LD50/ Daiwa Saltiga 50HKP/ Penn Trq40g2
Title: Re: Advise on which is better- Daiwa Saltiga LD50/ Daiwa Saltiga 50HKP/ Penn Trq40g2
Post by: Fritz on November 30, 2012, 01:44:49 PM
Jaffer... the Saltiga Lever Drag and the Penn Torque/Fathom are not "ordinary" multipliers - they work on a free floating spool shaft, which makes them difficult to cast even for seasoned anglers.
For pulling power, they are all much of a muchness, having drags that will seldom, if ever, get used to the max.
The Penn Trq has double dog pawls and an elongated Anti-reverse bearing, making it's anti-reverse system much better than any Daiwa. Whether this will be a factor is a subject for conjecture. If you're continually catching 100kg + sharks, then it is certainly something to consider.
But the Penn Trq comes without a Centrifugal braking system, which doesn't help the castability, making it probably the most difficult multiplier I know to control in the cast.

Weighing all these things up, as I said earlier, out of the list you have chosen, the Saltiga HKP is the one to go for.


Tony is right. I recently bought myself a LD50 and even though I've been casting with a multiplier for years, I battled initially until I figured out the reel works (i.e. cast control knob is same as drag knob). Took me 2 days at Kosi to get my casting up to scratch. If it were my money, I'd go for the Saltiga 50HKP (Gold spool).

In fact their is one at Kings on sale now for a steel.


How much Fritz?
It was just under 4K, their are LD for R2 and 2,5K.
I have allready gone well over my tackle budget for this month. :hehe:
Title: Re: Advise on which is better- Daiwa Saltiga LD50/ Daiwa Saltiga 50HKP/ Penn Trq40g2
Post by: Ray Hall on November 30, 2012, 01:51:34 PM
May i ask why not a good old SL50SH / Grandwave / or even the Saltist in the 50 size?
 
These reels are much cheaper and are up to the task - we have caught some big kingies on the infamous rocks of Goathill in Tofo, as well as some big Jonnies off the beach, all with the SL50SH. If you really want you can upgrade the drag washers to the carbontex ones - super smooth.
 
Just my 2CW.


agree i would first get a saltist and a size 40 one.  Its one of those must have in my possession reels of all time.  start there....
Title: Re: Advise on which is better- Daiwa Saltiga LD50/ Daiwa Saltiga 50HKP/ Penn Trq40g2
Post by: Ray Hall on November 30, 2012, 01:56:22 PM
I'm in market for a reel.  I have no experience with a multiplier but i want something that will last.  Its got to have raw power and i am leaning towards the LD50. I have seen the reviews and it pulls like a tow truck.  I cant cast with a multiplier so i will learn to get the distance i need.  i have ruled out the Trinidad 30 already (brand preference i guess).  Andwhat would I put on the reel?  Thinking of 50lb backing braid(600m) with 200m 40lb mono and 30m of leader. 

Any thoughts? :dwa: :penn: :penn: :mp:


my honest opinion is when its your first time with a multiplier, first get a SL30SH with a 13' foot rod.  Pracitse, Practise and then some more practise then buy a 50 size reel.
Title: Re: Advise on which is better- Daiwa Saltiga LD50/ Daiwa Saltiga 50HKP/ Penn Trq40g2
Post by: Weedeater on November 30, 2012, 02:01:54 PM
Jaffer... the Saltiga Lever Drag and the Penn Torque/Fathom are not "ordinary" multipliers - they work on a free floating spool shaft, which makes them difficult to cast even for seasoned anglers.
For pulling power, they are all much of a muchness, having drags that will seldom, if ever, get used to the max.
The Penn Trq has double dog pawls and an elongated Anti-reverse bearing, making it's anti-reverse system much better than any Daiwa. Whether this will be a factor is a subject for conjecture. If you're continually catching 100kg + sharks, then it is certainly something to consider.
But the Penn Trq comes without a Centrifugal braking system, which doesn't help the castability, making it probably the most difficult multiplier I know to control in the cast.

Weighing all these things up, as I said earlier, out of the list you have chosen, the Saltiga HKP is the one to go for.


Tony is right. I recently bought myself a LD50 and even though I've been casting with a multiplier for years, I battled initially until I figured out the reel works (i.e. cast control knob is same as drag knob). Took me 2 days at Kosi to get my casting up to scratch. If it were my money, I'd go for the Saltiga 50HKP (Gold spool).

In fact their is one at Kings on sale now for a steel.


Thanks Fritz, tempting but I can't.


How much Fritz?
It was just under 4K, their are LD for R2 and 2,5K.
I have allready gone well over my tackle budget for this month. :hehe:
Title: Re: Advise on which is better- Daiwa Saltiga LD50/ Daiwa Saltiga 50HKP/ Penn Trq40g2
Post by: Fritz on November 30, 2012, 02:28:24 PM
Jaffer... the Saltiga Lever Drag and the Penn Torque/Fathom are not "ordinary" multipliers - they work on a free floating spool shaft, which makes them difficult to cast even for seasoned anglers.
For pulling power, they are all much of a muchness, having drags that will seldom, if ever, get used to the max.
The Penn Trq has double dog pawls and an elongated Anti-reverse bearing, making it's anti-reverse system much better than any Daiwa. Whether this will be a factor is a subject for conjecture. If you're continually catching 100kg + sharks, then it is certainly something to consider.
But the Penn Trq comes without a Centrifugal braking system, which doesn't help the castability, making it probably the most difficult multiplier I know to control in the cast.

Weighing all these things up, as I said earlier, out of the list you have chosen, the Saltiga HKP is the one to go for.


Tony is right. I recently bought myself a LD50 and even though I've been casting with a multiplier for years, I battled initially until I figured out the reel works (i.e. cast control knob is same as drag knob). Took me 2 days at Kosi to get my casting up to scratch. If it were my money, I'd go for the Saltiga 50HKP (Gold spool).

In fact their is one at Kings on sale now for a steel.


Thanks Fritz, tempting but I can't.


How much Fritz?
It was just under 4K, their are LD for R2 and 2,5K.
I have allready gone well over my tackle budget for this month. :hehe:

Just over 12K
Title: Re: Advise on which is better- Daiwa Saltiga LD50/ Daiwa Saltiga 50HKP/ Penn Trq40g2
Post by: Prego on November 30, 2012, 02:34:45 PM
May i ask why not a good old SL50SH / Grandwave / or even the Saltist in the 50 size?
 
These reels are much cheaper and are up to the task - we have caught some big kingies on the infamous rocks of Goathill in Tofo, as well as some big Jonnies off the beach, all with the SL50SH. If you really want you can upgrade the drag washers to the carbontex ones - super smooth.
 
Just my 2CW.
How the hell can we believe you, how the hell can we believe you  :hehe: .................... where the pics??  :hnthnt: :hnthnt:
 
 
Title: Re: Advise on which is better- Daiwa Saltiga LD50/ Daiwa Saltiga 50HKP/ Penn Trq40g2
Post by: skip on December 03, 2012, 07:40:24 AM
May i ask why not a good old SL50SH / Grandwave / or even the Saltist in the 50 size?
 
These reels are much cheaper and are up to the task - we have caught some big kingies on the infamous rocks of Goathill in Tofo, as well as some big Jonnies off the beach, all with the SL50SH. If you really want you can upgrade the drag washers to the carbontex ones - super smooth.
 
Just my 2CW.
How the hell can we believe you, how the hell can we believe you  :hehe: .................... where the pics??  :hnthnt: :hnthnt:

eish. I will have to have a look. Was some time ago....
 
BTW kings are having a sale and they have a few of the reels mentioned above at great discounts.
 
 
SimplePortal 2.3.7 © 2008-2026, SimplePortal