ULTIMATE ANGLING - the Ultimate SA Fishing website

General Angling Topics => Shore Angling => Topic started by: Lenny on June 07, 2012, 08:27:51 PM

Title: Are we fishing too heavy gear for edibles ?
Post by: Lenny on June 07, 2012, 08:27:51 PM
Ok , I have thinking alot of this , Are we [the edible guys] fishing to heavy , I mean Reels , Rods , Leaders ect .
So yes theres a large Light tackle group of anglers in Sa .


But what is light ?


I know i cant make a comparison to Freshwater Bass fishing , but from my days as A  bass fisherman , the lightest line ALWAYS got beter and bigger fish .


I think Ray Hall mentioned , it on another thread too.


Most of the Big Kob in rivers get caught on light tackle , I have seen a good mate of mine landing a 100lbs Kob in the breede on a Bass rod and Daiwa Jupiter with 14lbs MONO . Yes we did follow the fish , yes there was not loads of snags ,But it was an epic fight , I will admit from a C&R perspective going very light might not be the best thing to do as the fish might be so tired and just die.


Thing is , with Braids and ultra strong rods , why would you fish a 12foot rod with 80lbs braid , if you can fish a 9 foot , grinder and 20lbs Braid , yes I am aware of condisions ect ect .
Just want to know some of the experts opinions with regards to the subject at hand ?
Any thoughts guys ?
Title: Re: Are we fishing to heavy gear ?
Post by: MIKE PIKE on June 07, 2012, 08:44:28 PM
Good topic Lenny , and agreed i think sometimes we do go a bit heavy on the tackle for eds , but then its a sense of security , more a case of if i'd used tackle a bit stronger i might have still landed the fish instead of being broken off .. etc , nothing worse than loosing what could have been a P.B or record fish by being out-gunned i think the  species you target and the conditions of the shore , eg : lots of rocks\ sandy beaches etc  determines what tackle to use , although with the onset of H.M.G rods , braids , technology in the reels and material used , one can go lighter on the tackle used , but still land some large fish ,advantage of lighter tacle is bite detection especially on the shy feeders and a huge fun factor when on with a decent fish on light tackle , which also hones and sharpens the skills instead of just cranking the fish in to take a pic and release. :-)   
Title: Re: Are we fishing to heavy gear ?
Post by: Nemesis. on June 07, 2012, 09:00:12 PM
Totally agree Lenny
With the Grinder evolution, most guys here in Natal have packed their heavy tackle away. Every one has scaled down to Medium rods, grinders, 0.26mm braid(on Average) and smaller baits, and to tell you what, there has been some amazing fish landed so far that was once thought to be only targeted with heavy tackle.
Title: Re: Are we fishing to heavy gear ?
Post by: Half-Pint on June 07, 2012, 09:08:37 PM
The only thing with fishing light is when that 1 in a 100 fish picks you up you kick yourself for fishing light. The real question is do you want to enjoy fighting that 1 fish or the 99 others?
Title: Re: Are we fishing to heavy gear ?
Post by: Lenny on June 07, 2012, 09:39:54 PM
The only thing with fishing light is when that 1 in a 100 fish picks you up you kick yourself for fishing light. The real question is do you want to enjoy fighting that 1 fish or the 99 others?


I understand Bradley , BUT i will rather land one good fish , on light gear , than to drag 99 and feel nothing .you might have not have got a pull on heavier gear .
Leon Goodman legend in fishing circles in CPT , always told us , 'Its not quantity , but quality of the catch '
Title: Re: Are we fishing to heavy gear ?
Post by: Lenny on June 07, 2012, 09:55:25 PM
Club angling I can understand , you need points and theres limited time ect ect .What Mike Pike pointed out the sence of 'security '
Fishing heavier might be more suitable for more types of situations , I do think it takes the 'sport' out of fishing .
I think a big part of landing a PB is the fairness of the fight , or am I missing something ? Alltough I am not saying go and Target Crackers with your 9foot rod and 20 lbs Braid , because a Cracker will snap your Small rod a Toothpick and floss with your braid , and the bricks is not so conducive to light tackle . One can DEF scale down your mono when fishing from sandy beaches .
I think going light , has got a certian kind of responsibility ,and one should apply this to the Area you fishing , the target species ect .
Thanks for your input so far guys ! :-)
Title: Re: Are we fishing to heavy gear ?
Post by: ianf on June 08, 2012, 12:06:54 AM
Agree 100% about going lighter for edibles. Not only is heavy tackle a lot of work, but it can take the fun factor out of fishing. My "big" stick is an assassin medium 13 and a half foot,  but I derive vast amount more fun fishing with a my 2 berkley air rods (a 9 and a 10 footer). Catching a 40cm shad on a Berkley air ilike catching a monster on the assassin.
 
If fishing for edibles, my vote is definitely go lighter.
Title: Re: Are we fishing to heavy gear ?
Post by: Half-Pint on June 08, 2012, 06:11:00 AM
Lenny I agree 100% with you. Perhaps I should have answered my question duh enjoying catching 99 fish is much better than sending them water skiing as you winch them in.

The upshot is that the one that got away can be bragged about for ages :hehe:
Title: Re: Are we fishing to heavy gear ?
Post by: Kumz on June 08, 2012, 06:18:47 AM
Totally agree Lenny
With the Grinder evolution, most guys here in Natal have packed their heavy tackle away. Every one has scaled down to Medium rods, grinders, 0.26mm braid(on Average) and smaller baits, and to tell you what, there has been some amazing fish landed so far that was once thought to be only targeted with heavy tackle.
:corrct:
 
Agree 100 % ....
Title: Re: Are we fishing to heavy gear ?
Post by: SAfish on June 08, 2012, 07:44:04 AM
My edible tackle is an Exage 110H paired with a SL30, loaded with 9.1kg mono. The other day in the surf I played around with my 7ft rod, Abu 5600 C3 loaded with 5.5kg mono and landed a small Steenbras. Although small, the fish still gave me a good fight on light tackle.
The sad question is: how many big fish are still around to warrant the use of heavy tackle? I always say, if the small fish are on the bite, scale down your tackle and have some fun.  :yipee:  :sreel:
Title: Re: Are we fishing to heavy gear ?
Post by: REEFMAN on June 08, 2012, 08:19:37 AM
My motto is always go as light as the conditions will allow. Small tackle and hooks catch all fish, big hooks only catch big fish!
Title: Re: Are we fishing to heavy gear ?
Post by: tkei on June 08, 2012, 08:26:07 AM
Its a similar thing deepsea (on the bottom fishing front at least). Why do most guys from el to natal bottomfish with 80lb braid on 9 or 10"kp's.
The average fish is probably 3kgs and a good fish 10kgs. Sure there are exceptions like coppers, the big dagga kob etc, but even geelbek are 6kgs avg and a big 1 9 or 10kgs. using 40kg braid is ioverkill (ja, ja, ja the tax man taketh i know).
The problem with fishing light deepsea )and off the rocks is its expensive tackle wise. lots of snap offs (and the resulting polution as it can be lots of line that snaps off. swings and round abouts i guess. if its shad etc i only use my light 7ft nexave and 6lb braid.
 
Title: Re: Are we fishing to heavy gear ?
Post by: WalkersKiller on June 08, 2012, 08:31:53 AM
Great topic Lenny.

My moto is fish light. The only time I will fish heavy gear is when I am targeting a non ed and even then I fish light.

For me angling is a sport as much as it is a passion. I have caught all sorts of awesome fish on light gear, but I have lost many PB's as well. In the end that is part of fishing, rather build up to eventually getting that PB fish on the light tackle than pulling the fish out on top of the water. I always fish light line, small hooks, 6-9 foot rods and small grinders in the surf, and man do I have a lot of fun. The beauty of it is even a 15cm Karanteen or Barbel become memorable catches just because they have a fighting chance and you have to use your skills to try get them out. Have lost some big Bronze Bream, Kob and recently a Steenie, but I will eventually get them  :-)
Title: Re: Are we fishing to heavy gear ?
Post by: Hooch on June 08, 2012, 08:33:45 AM
If i may throw a spanner in the works here.....
I understand the motto of going light etc, but here is my gripe with it. Now you hook that monster cob you always dreamed about on 6kg line and a ultra light spinning stick. 2hours into the fight you land your fish. Stocked that you made this acievement and then you realize, but hell, my fish is dead :unhap So is this a achievement or just plain murder?
My point is why go after fish that will never survive the fight on light gear. They will fight themselves to exhaustion due to you not being able to put enought presure on the fish with light line.
Food for thought
Title: Re: Are we fishing to heavy gear ?
Post by: WJ on June 08, 2012, 08:45:33 AM
Good post Hooch, I agree 100%
Title: Re: Are we fishing to heavy gear ?
Post by: WalkersKiller on June 08, 2012, 08:47:44 AM
Very good point Hooch, theres absolutely no doubt with that.

How would one work around it though? Is there a way on light tackle? Probably not. I know personally as a light tackle surf angler I have spent hours revving fish. The Kob would definitely be exhausted, but then it is the anglers responsibility to release and revive that Kob, even if it takes another 2 hours. This is where the light tackle angler must step up and realise he will exhaust a lot of big fish and if he plans to release them he needs to put that same effort back to make sure that fish is just as strong when he first took the bait.
Title: Re: Are we fishing to heavy gear ?
Post by: Hooch on June 08, 2012, 08:58:49 AM
Very good point Hooch, theres absolutely no doubt with that.

How would one work around it though? Is there a way on light tackle? Probably not. I know personally as a light tackle surf angler I have spent hours revving fish. The Kob would definitely be exhausted, but then it is the anglers responsibility to release and revive that Kob, even if it takes another 2 hours. This is where the light tackle angler must step up and realise he will exhaust a lot of big fish and if he plans to release them he needs to put that same effort back to make sure that fish is just as strong when he first took the bait.
Gareth boet, fully understand were you come from, BUT (And its a big one) how many anglers will spend that extra time to revive the fish? Not alot, i can asure you of this.
Even more alarming is the fact that some big fish are consistantly lost on light gear. Will this fish survive the fact that its now swimming around with hooks, line sinkers all dangling from its mouth?
And to everyone that still say the hooks ext rusts away, yes it does, but the fish still has to swim around for days with this dangling from its mouth. will it survive? We will never know..........
Title: Re: Are we fishing to heavy gear ?
Post by: SAfish on June 08, 2012, 09:05:07 AM
I hear what you say Hooch and I agree to a certain extend. Fishing tackle technology have advanced to such an extend that we are now able to put a lot more pressure on a fish with light tackle. The drag systems are a lot better and smoother than before and with braid your line capacity has also increased a lot.
Like WK said, it is the responsibility of the angler to put in the time to revive his fish. Common sense should also prevail, don't try and do battle with a big fish with the lightest rod you can find. I would never recommend someone, that is not an accomplished angler, to do light tackle fishing for big fish. Rather opt for a medium or heavy set-up until you have enough experience to go light for big fish.
Title: Re: Are we fishing to heavy gear ?
Post by: WalkersKiller on June 08, 2012, 09:07:41 AM
100% bru, I know very few anglers will put that effort in, which is why I say if someone wants to target a big fish on light tackle it is their responsibility to handle and revive the fish until it is ready to swim off. But then again not many anglers would even bother, and unfortunately I have seen it.

With regard to tackle, yes you get burned off a lot and lose plenty of tackle and you are right you will never know if it will survive or not, but the exact same thing happens to guys who get burned off on heavier tackle and surely then it would be easier for a fish to swim around with a size 2 hook and a 1 ounce compared to a 4/0 and a 6 ounce grappie?
Title: Re: Are we fishing to heavy gear ?
Post by: Hooch on June 08, 2012, 09:11:34 AM
I hear what you say Hooch and I agree to a certain extend. Fishing tackle technology have advanced to such an extend that we are now able to put a lot more pressure on a fish with light tackle. The drag systems are a lot better and smoother than before and with braid your line capacity has also increased a lot.
Like WK said, it is the responsibility of the angler to put in the time to revive his fish. Common sense should also prevail, don't try and do battle with a big fish with the lightest rod you can find. I would never recommend someone, that is not an accomplished angler, to do light tackle fishing for big fish. Rather opt for a medium or heavy set-up until you have enough experience to go light for big fish.
Hermann, i agree whith you on the modern technology part etc. But how many anglers out there do fish with this modern technology? Not alot.
Even so on say 12lb braid and modern reel with pimped out drag system and hooking a 30kg cuta from the surf. How long will this fight last? Will the fish survive?
Makes one think.............
Title: Re: Are we fishing to heavy gear ?
Post by: Hooch on June 08, 2012, 09:18:22 AM
100% bru, I know very few anglers will put that effort in, which is why I say if someone wants to target a big fish on light tackle it is their responsibility to handle and revive the fish until it is ready to swim off. But then again not many anglers would even bother, and unfortunately I have seen it.

With regard to tackle, yes you get burned off a lot and lose plenty of tackle and you are right you will never know if it will survive or not, but the exact same thing happens to guys who get burned off on heavier tackle and surely then it would be easier for a fish to swim around with a size 2 hook and a 1 ounce compared to a 4/0 and a 6 ounce grappie?
The point im making is, fish will die on light line. Period. Were with heavy line you can get the fish to shore in no time. 90% of the time the fish is still "Green" when you land it. This means its not exausted and will swim of strongly in a blink of an eye. Less lactic acid build up in the stummic due to  shorter fight etc. That is why big fish die. Stress causes lactic acid build up in their stummic due to pro longed fight on lite line.
Title: Re: Are we fishing to heavy gear ?
Post by: tkei on June 08, 2012, 09:21:10 AM
I would never recommend someone, that is not an accomplished angler, to do light tackle fishing for big fish. Rather opt for a medium or heavy set-up until you have enough experience to go light for big fish.

Very NB point made here. You dont see charter boats heading out after marlin on 10lb tackle with guys on their first trip. You do however get guys who regularly chase marlin on tackle you will think is too light for bonnies. they however know what they are doing. even with this they have many tears, for the 1 success.
responsible angling to maximise the enjoyment. A newbie wont enjoy the experience catching a 40kg kob in a river having fought it for 3hrs. he will however enjoy it on 10kg tackle or what whatever. rememebr fishing is a blood sport. fish die (be it the bait we use or the target) but make sure they dont die in vain.
If you expect the average kob to be 30+kg's done use 3kg line. if they are 5kgs by aL means go ahead. You may get lucky ana dhook a 20-50kg guy and have the fight of your life, but match tackle to the target species. you cant go overkill all the time INCASE the big one comes along.
 
Title: Re: Are we fishing to heavy gear ?
Post by: John F on June 08, 2012, 09:22:02 AM
Even so on say 12lb braid and modern reel with pimped out drag system and hooking a 30kg cuta from the surf. How long will this fight last? Will the fish survive?
Makes one think.............

30 kg couta will always die... never mind the tackle used! :crzy
Title: Re: Are we fishing to heavy gear ?
Post by: Half-Pint on June 08, 2012, 09:22:24 AM
Firstly we need to accept that fishing IS a blood sport. Sometimes fish will die. You also have to accept that at some point you will hook something too big for your tackle. Check out Angling with Blackfin, they were sliding a standard mackie off the Island at Mazeppa fishing blades and trini 50s. Wes or Rob got a pick up that dam near spooled them! Should we now start fishing tiagras because of that one fish? I don't think so.

The key I would say is to know your abilities. When targeting sharks I use max tackle because I don't have the experience to land them on lighter tackle.

Also be realistic with your tackle choices. Using 6lb braid to scratch in the gulleys for blacktail is probably ok. Using 6lb braid to target bronze bream or kob is not!
Title: Re: Are we fishing to heavy gear ?
Post by: WalkersKiller on June 08, 2012, 09:24:11 AM
Nice debate going on here  :uarocks

Tkei great points

@ Hooch, with response to Tkei's points I think the solution to fishing light is that when you are targeting larger fish or you know larger fish are in the area, do not fish light tackle.
Title: Re: Are we fishing to heavy gear ?
Post by: WalkersKiller on June 08, 2012, 09:25:07 AM
Firstly we need to accept that fishing IS a blood sport. Sometimes fish will die. You also have to accept that at some point you will hook something too big for your tackle. Check out Angling with Blackfin, they were sliding a standard mackie off the Island at Mazeppa fishing blades and trini 50s. Wes or Rob got a pick up that dam near spooled them! Should we now start fishing tiagras because of that one fish? I don't think so.

The key I would say is to know your abilities. When targeting sharks I use max tackle because I don't have the experience to land them on lighter tackle.

Also be realistic with your tackle choices. Using 6lb braid to scratch in the gulleys for blacktail is probably ok. Using 6lb braid to target bronze bream or kob is not!
Speak for yourself  :crzy
Title: Re: Are we fishing to heavy gear ?
Post by: Hooch on June 08, 2012, 09:25:27 AM
Even so on say 12lb braid and modern reel with pimped out drag system and hooking a 30kg cuta from the surf. How long will this fight last? Will the fish survive?
Makes one think.............

30 kg couta will always die... never mind the tackle used! :crzy
Classic Marcos :rck"
Title: Re: Are we fishing to heavy gear ?
Post by: TUNAMAN on June 08, 2012, 09:51:35 AM
Even so on say 12lb braid and modern reel with pimped out drag system and hooking a 30kg cuta from the surf. How long will this fight last? Will the fish survive?
Makes one think.............

30 kg couta will always die... never mind the tackle used! :crzy
SOSATIES!!!
Title: Re: Are we fishing to heavy gear ?
Post by: SAfish on June 08, 2012, 09:53:00 AM
The guys that are fishing for the pot do not normally use light tackle anyway. Anglers that have a passion for light tackle fishing, like WK, will put in the time to revive their fish. You cannot save all the fish you catch, but everyone you release successfully will make a difference. Lets not get carried away with discussing C&R as it is a controversial subject on its own. The bottom line for me is that I will fish as light as possible that the conditions and size fish allow me to. 
 
Title: Re: Are we fishing to heavy gear ?
Post by: TUNAMAN on June 08, 2012, 10:01:51 AM
There are two sides to all the choices. Some marlin comps now have a 20 pound line class however the guys are Pros. They break off any fish that they reckon will probably die or break them off anyway. Personally when scratching I go light as that is what scratching entails. If I were to loose a big kob due to it so be it as I was not prepared or targeting it.

With jigging I went big. Used 130 pound braid etc. It however takes a big fish or two to have you realise what actually is required. I have witnessed TOMMO spooled before on Stella 20000 and there is nothing you can do because you only have so much drag. If your knots are right etc you're max line is 80 pound the rest is just a waste and unnecessary.

With light tackle I have managed plenty Shad under the noses of many a big rod Shad angler on Chokka nogal when they never got a pull. Certainly has it's advantages.

With a fish out there swimming around with tackle/hooks/line etc, I'm not to concerned with as many instances has proven they get rid of it no problem. Like when a barble is snagged on say 30 pound line, he pops it like candy floss. Sure same will go with other species. Similarly 7kg fish on a 150pound line daisy chain, when you get more than one they pop the trace like there is nothing, they just need a fixed point as they are way stronger than what we exspect.

My 2c is balance it out and each to his own.
Title: Re: Are we fishing to heavy gear ?
Post by: Lenny on June 08, 2012, 11:03:29 AM
Some lekker input here guys Thanks .
Very valid point form most of the guys , Tkei , Hooch , WK , Reefman ect thanks .
As I too mentioned , the responsibility than goes hand in hand with going light ,and also the more experianced guys can 'take chances' with light gear .I also did point out the effects light tackle has on big fish.then theres Fish like Yellowtail that no matter what gear you are using they fight till they die ,I have experiaced this a fair number of times oooo i love my YT fishing .
One undoubted advantage is the fact thats its light , you can walk far , fish all day without breaking your back and keep your rod out of the pension pipe ...
Agian , I like having a fish on the the other end  , and have a fair fight after all its a fair opponent .

lekker contributions keepem coming ! w;k [size=78%] [/size]
 
Title: Re: Are we fishing to heavy gear ?
Post by: Elvis on June 08, 2012, 01:04:24 PM
Question: When fishing light tackle and you get to hook a large fish, it will take you longer to land the fish obviously, will the chances of releasing that fish back into the sea not be more difficult because of the length of the fight and how tired the fish is, compared to landing a big fish quicker on heavier tackle and giving it a better chance of survival once released ?
Title: Re: Are we fishing to heavy gear ?
Post by: Rory mundy on June 08, 2012, 01:32:35 PM
Even so on say 12lb braid and modern reel with pimped out drag system and hooking a 30kg cuta from the surf. How long will this fight last? Will the fish survive?
Makes one think.............

30 kg couta will always die... never mind the tackle used! :crzy
SOSATIES!!!

thats called reincarnation
Title: Re: Are we fishing to heavy gear ?
Post by: Lenny on June 08, 2012, 01:45:45 PM
Even so on say 12lb braid and modern reel with pimped out drag system and hooking a 30kg cuta from the surf. How long will this fight last? Will the fish survive?
Makes one think.............

30 kg couta will always die... never mind the tackle used! :crzy
SOSATIES!!!

thats called reincarnation
:hyst: :hyst: :hyst: :hyst: :hyst:
Title: Re: Are we fishing to heavy gear ?
Post by: Lenny on June 08, 2012, 01:48:25 PM
Question: When fishing light tackle and you get to hook a large fish, it will take you longer to land the fish obviously, will the chances of releasing that fish back into the sea not be more difficult because of the length of the fight and how tired the fish is, compared to landing a big fish quicker on heavier tackle and giving it a better chance of survival once released ?


Yes you're right , the thing is as it has been mentioned do you rather wanna land a Blacktail on .45 line , or would you rather land a Blacktail on 14lbs line ...
Lets be honest , the days where you hook a 'line breaker' is far and few ...
Title: Re: Are we fishing too heavy gear for edibles ?
Post by: Parasite on June 08, 2012, 03:48:55 PM
Absolute interesting debate going on. I don't believe there is a "right or wrong"side to it. I think it is personal choice. My style either fishing fresh water for bass, or rock and surf or from my kayak, I approach each discipline of fishing giving thought to the fish I am to target, water conditions and obsticals, ie rocks/trees grass etc. before applying that style and technic of fishing. I too consider, am I fishing "for the pot"or am I fishing for the "sport", catch & release.
As the saying goes - "different strokes for different folks"tight lines all.
Title: Re: Are we fishing to heavy gear ?
Post by: strandloper on June 09, 2012, 01:19:38 AM
Even so on say 12lb braid and modern reel with pimped out drag system and hooking a 30kg cuta from the surf. How long will this fight last? Will the fish survive?
Makes one think.............

30 kg couta will always die... never mind the tackle used! :crzy
Classic Marcos :rck"

Good one Marcos!

 :hehe:
Title: Re: Are we fishing too heavy gear for edibles ?
Post by: BETTYS on June 11, 2012, 02:52:56 PM
Hi Guys
 
I just think that you must,make sure of what fish you are goint to target,before deciding on your gear. I use light gear for Galjoen,as I know that is what I am fishing for. And for shad and all the other smaller fish.
 
But when targeting Steenbra,Kabeljou and bigger fish,I really think you shoul go to medium  gear.
 
 :fshn:
SimplePortal 2.3.7 © 2008-2026, SimplePortal