ULTIMATE ANGLING - the Ultimate SA Fishing website

General Angling Topics => Shore Angling => Topic started by: Sharkslayer on August 03, 2010, 09:05:09 PM

Title: Sharing of fishing spots
Post by: Sharkslayer on August 03, 2010, 09:05:09 PM
Last year i followed a few threads on another forum where spots was announced left right and center.
It was actually quite spectacular to see all the fish that was caught from these spots. However this year that spots is not producing at all. Now that brings me back to the question. Can a spot be over fished and what is the consequences of this.

I myself named a spot after i caught a few nice Steenbra's. That was the last time that i would ever do that on an open forum, where it seems that there is always those that just sit and wait for these spots to be announced. They then pounce on these spots and it becomes a free for all.
I believe that we all worked hard to go and do what we love doing best. Fish our favorite spots wit those that we trust!!!!

Anny-way to those lurkers i just wanna say
:flck: :crzy

Cheers
Sakkie
Title: Re: Sharing of fishing spots
Post by: Sailfish on August 03, 2010, 10:13:40 PM
Stem saam Sakkie. Man kan jou pm en vra vir raat oor n sekere plek en jy kan hom in die regte rigtig verwys om ook n suksesvolle hengeluitstappie te beleef. Die goeie en gereeld vishouplekke is net te min en kosbaar om aan die hele wereld uit te basuin. Daar is sekere plekke wat sensitief is teen oorontgunning en nie naby aanvullende visbron areas is nie. Ek smile tog te lekker as ek my gereelde ou rotsie so alleen sien staan en wag vir my. Niks so erg om op n kol te kom waar jy gereeld hengel en die plek is toe met mense wat geen vis ongeag sy maat trug plaas of jy loop jou bankvas in n magdom gemors wat jou al n myl ver laat ruik dis jou voorland vir die dag se hengel nie. Mens kry beswaarlik n vis uit op Max se riwwe sonder om eers met n ou lyn wat orals hak en soos n versperring net buite bereik voor jou in die sloep le en al wat seewier en papier daarop vasklou. Share with them you trust to keep it clean and who will abide with MCM rules and regulations.
Title: Re: Sharing of fishing spots
Post by: Zetti on August 04, 2010, 07:19:59 AM
Agree 100% Sakkie. Share with those who you know will respect the sea and its creatures. There are so many "lurkers" as you call them who want to fish untill there is nothing left to fish and then move on to the next spot.
 
You can probably say in a post that there are huge sharks coming out the vaal river, and the next day the lurkers will be there with their sliding baits.
 
In another thread i asked someone about a location and they (in a very respectful manner) replied that they do not want to disclose the exact location for good reason, which i respect.
Title: Re: Sharing of fishing spots
Post by: Marthin on August 04, 2010, 08:24:38 AM
Sakkie ek stem nie heeltemal saam nie.  Het ook nie laas keer nie.  I don't think the steenbras histeria on the west coast was fuelled by the other forum or any forum for that matter.  There were way to many people that i doubt ever owned or worked a computer fishing there.  The guys Brent nearly bliksemmed at Haakgat i think were definately not computer literate.

The bellman runs at Monwabesi is a classic example.  The one spot you might be alluring to regarding galjoen, has not had the storms to open it up like we had last year.  I think many spots haven't opened up the way they should, and the SE for a day or 2 every second week isnt helping either.  I have a thread running on the other forum specifically regarding galjoen.  There are a lot more small ones around this year, with some really big fish here and there, one at 60+cm, but none of the 2-6 40cm guys comeing from one spot.

I still think having a large group of conservation minded indivuals fishing a stretch regularly is better, (for instance Brett chasing the guys away keeping the undersize steenies, because he was with a big group of same minded guys), than simply hoping and praying uneducated people won't find "your" spot.

But to each his own.  If Ray Hall never gives a spot away again i wouldnt blame him.  The massacre that followed in Melkbaai is really deserving of a few warm ears being handed out.  So if he or anyone else (u seem to have experienced the same), doesnt want to put up a spot that's their choice, but i wouldnt blame someone else that does either.  As long as the MCM rules are kept i think any spot is sustainable.  I'll get the figures from Wikus, but a lot of galjoen for example leave De Hoop (it's tonnes), every year to go to other areas.  I think there are enough unfishable areas surrounding these "sensitive" areas that will repopulate.

The steenbras on the west coast this year didnt magically appear.  Obviously somewhere someone is doing something right allowing these fish to breed somewhere, specifically because most caught were of the same size.
Title: Re: Sharing of fishing spots
Post by: landshark on August 04, 2010, 08:50:00 AM
My view on this:

If a specific spot is at that moment in time really hot and producing fish then I will only share that spot with friends and people I know I can trust.

Other than I have no problem sharing general info on a specific geographic area publicly.
Title: Re: Sharing of fishing spots
Post by: TUNAMAN on August 04, 2010, 09:26:31 AM
There is so much to mention on this topic. Here is my 2 c worth.


1. Do not post it on the forum because any non member can also read it unless it is a file that requires downloading.
2. Recent ESA episode the guys were catching shad in KZN. The subsistence fisherman (R5.00 per license) were hauling over 20 an angler by the time the ESA guys left. No one knows where this ended.
3. Members that have been on a forum for a while and are active members will not over exploit a spot.
4. Any non public spots I keep separate under the name of the originator. Should anyone ask for it I have him contact the originator.


A lot of members here might not even get to a spot in a lifetime because we are all busy with our earnings and geographically we are spread across the country.


What is required is to keep it among the members and the members that receive this information to honour the sender by keeping it to yourself. If anyone else requires it, they are free to contact the originator of the information and he can decide at his discretion whether he wants to release the info or not.
Title: Re: Sharing of fishing spots
Post by: nico on August 04, 2010, 10:05:24 AM
Hmm... this is an interesting discussion.
 
In any location, whether R&S or Skiboat, there will be common, well known spots. For someone new to a location I will happily share them.
 
For my own, hard earned marks, I only share with people that I would fish with anyway, maybe I am selfish but I know I keep to the law and I don't know if YOU would if fishing fever hits.
 
With spots I get from others, I don't share at all. You where given these in confidence, so be a man and respect another man's (woman's) spots.
 
Just yesterday a well respected angler on this forum offered me the marks to his absolutely cooking spot that has had us all jealous. I really appreciated it, but as I am currently without a boat I would only ever visit it on someone elses boat, who would then mark it and who knows where it would end up... so as hard as it was to do I asked him to please not send me the details.
 
 
Title: Re: Sharing of fishing spots
Post by: TUNAMAN on August 04, 2010, 10:16:01 AM
Here is a good example. When fishing Durban during an Interprovincial comp NICO and others shared some marks with me. Some general and some he prefers to keep quiet. So the ones he shared in confidence remains as such.


So if you really need the marks then you need to take "The NIC" with you..... :hehe:  Not sure why I  did not think of it first.
Title: Re: Sharing of fishing spots
Post by: LUPO on August 04, 2010, 11:38:16 AM
This is my 2 cents as I think in my case the circumstances are quite different to most of you seasond fisherman.

Firstly I must say that each and every one of you have valid points, and in all your points I suppose one can make an argument either way.

I have lived in CT all my life. When I was in my teens I used to fish on the CT harbour break-water with my dad.  ( Stockfish was the catch of the day then for us).  I am now 39( almost) and have only started fishing again this year.  When I started again, none of my friends or family fished and my knowledge of every aspect of fishing ( tackle, spots, conservation of the sea and the coastline, the right conditions etc) was and probably still is very limited. 

I found a forum at the begining of the year that was a source of endless information and so I started to learn.  I joined a social  R&S fishing club and all the members have been fantastic in helping me.  ( You will recognise me on the beach quite easily, I am the one following them around, carrying way to much gear. LOL). I am now a member of UA and I just can't get enough, every day I learn something new.

Now to the main point, I have been given and been taken to many a special spot this year and I am sad to say, I have BLANKED.  So with me around the fish are safe, well for now anyway.

This has not dampened my enthusiasim for this great sport as I too enjoy the many other parts of fishing other than the "VAS PAPPA'.  The sound of the sea, the fresh sea air and the peacefulness of sitting there with rod in hand and looking out at the horizon with the sun coming up.  Absolute bliss.

What I am getting at is that you can take a horse to water, but you can't make him drink.  Take a fisheman to a spot and he won't definately catch a fish.

I value all the knowledge that everyone of you post on this fantastic forum and I respect your need to keep certain spots to yourselves, but remember not everyone out there is trying to find a new spot and exploit it.

Some of us just want to learn and catch a fish.

PS: Stightly off the topic - How many of you fisherman that smoke, actually take your stompies back with you?  I do.
Title: Re: Sharing of fishing spots
Post by: Ray Hall on August 04, 2010, 12:53:51 PM
 :gprlz:
 
so we are the fish coming out?
Title: Re: Sharing of fishing spots
Post by: Homie on August 04, 2010, 01:00:18 PM
:gprlz:
 
so we are the fish coming out?


Dont Know....


The perfect person to ask would be a guy called Ray Hall !


oh, and  :welc:
Title: Re: Sharing of fishing spots
Post by: JasonF on August 04, 2010, 01:07:44 PM
I myself named a spot after i caught a few nice Steenbra's. That was the last time that i would ever do that on an open forum, where it seems that there is always those that just sit and wait for these spots to be announced. They then pounce on these spots and it becomes a free for all.
I believe that we all worked hard to go and do what we love doing best. Fish our favorite spots wit those that we trust!!!!


Trust jy my
Title: Re: Sharing of fishing spots
Post by: TUNAMAN on August 04, 2010, 01:27:14 PM
Here is a typical example. On another forum, not half as cool as UA  :uarocks , I posted a document on a forum. In the forum there is only 3 members discussing a particular subject yet the document has allready been downloaded 5 times.
Title: Re: Sharing of fishing spots
Post by: Fluffy on August 04, 2010, 02:12:08 PM
Ai people....will just have to leeve it to the cape town oaks to
show
me the spots....
Title: Re: Sharing of fishing spots
Post by: Marthin on August 04, 2010, 04:06:07 PM
Loomis jyt steenbras gevang en my nie gese nie!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!  Ek hoop jou boog is nog steeds stukkend!!
Title: Re: Sharing of fishing spots
Post by: Sharkslayer on August 04, 2010, 04:39:05 PM
@ Loomis.... Ja Xlebo sal jou trust :hnthnt:

Title: Re: Sharing of fishing spots
Post by: Sharkslayer on August 04, 2010, 04:41:29 PM
:gprlz:
 
so we are the fish coming out?

 :welc:

 :pot: :pot: :pot: :pot: :pot: :+ :rotfl
Title: Re: Sharing of fishing spots
Post by: Sharkslayer on August 04, 2010, 04:54:43 PM

Sakkie ek stem nie heeltemal saam nie.  Het ook nie laas keer nie.
I don't think the steenbras histeria on the west coast was fuelled by the other forum or any forum for that matter.  There were way to many people that i doubt ever owned or worked a computer fishing there.  The guys Brent nearly bliksemmed at Haakgat i think were definately not computer literate.Marthin...Dont think that i agree completely. It takes just one guy with internet access to read and tel his buddy, his buddy tells another and so it goes on....Compounded interest. Look at what happened at Sonwabi, looked worst than Durban pier when the sardines run and the shad go bos.


T
he bellman runs at Monwabesi is a classic example.  The one spot you might be alluring to regarding galjoen, has not had the storms to open it up like we had last year.  I think many spots haven't opened up the way they should, and the SE for a day or 2 every second week isnt helping either.  I have a thread running on the other forum specifically regarding galjoen.  There are a lot more small ones around this year, with some really big fish here and there, one at 60+cm, but none of the 2-6 40cm guys coming from one spot. Don't think the storm is going to happen, but look at the wreck....How many fish has been caught there since the season started?

I still think having a large group of conservation minded indivuals fishing a stretch regularly is better, (for instance Brett chasing the guys away keeping the undersize steenies, because he was with a big group of same minded guys), than simply hoping and praying uneducated people won't find "your" spot. As for Brent I applaud his reaction to this (clap) (clap) But to each his own.  If Ray Hall never gives a spot away again i wouldnt blame him.  The massacre that followed in Melkbaai is really deserving of a few warm ears being handed out.  So if he or anyone else (u seem to have experienced the same), doesnt want to put up a spot that's their choice, but i wouldnt blame someone else that does either.  As long as the MCM rules are kept i think any spot is sustainable.  I'll get the figures from Wikus, but a lot of galjoen for example leave De Hoop (it's tonnes), every year to go to other areas.  I think there are enough unfishable areas surrounding these "sensitive" areas that will repopulate.

The steenbras on the west coast this year didnt magically appear.  Obviously somewhere someone is doing something right allowing these fish to breed somewhere, specifically because most caught were of the same size. Regarding the Steenbras at the spot you refer to. I have done a search and could not get reference to this spot from the "other site". It was only after it was mentioned on that site , that people got wind of it and it was tickets for that spot.   
I honestly believe that our fragile sea life can be over fished especially by irresponsible lurkers who take nobody else into consideration but themselves. Please take note that i am not referring to responsible people.
Title: Re: Sharing of fishing spots
Post by: midnight marlin on August 04, 2010, 09:14:54 PM
Hi Sakkie great pseudonym. I have just been keeping a low profile and not posted much.Just been waching things on the other forum and not commented much. However I have been active regarding fishing My two usual spots in False Bay have produced its fair share of fish.The Elf are really scarce and the Gallies must have left the country.I am of the firm belief that you should definately not publish your fishing spots on a open forum.I have been working a certain spot for about 3 weeks now finally last night it started producing.Between myself and my usual suspects we landed 3 Cob and 2 Elf.I just got back from the beach now.Got pulled flat twice but could not convert I guess that it could have been steenbras.This spot is known for huge steenies.If the conditions are simillar again on Saturday I will be going there again.
Three people can keep a secret if two of them are dead  :thmsup"
Title: Re: Sharing of fishing spots
Post by: hndray on August 04, 2010, 11:26:04 PM
Hi Sakkie great pseudonym. I have just been keeping a low profile and not posted much.Just been waching things on the other forum and not commented much. However I have been active regarding fishing My two usual spots in False Bay have produced its fair share of fish.The Elf are really scarce and the Gallies must have left the country.I am of the firm belief that you should definately not publish your fishing spots on a open forum.I have been working a certain spot for about 3 weeks now finally last night it started producing.Between myself and my usual suspects we landed 3 Cob and 2 Elf.I just got back from the beach now.Got pulled flat twice but could not convert I guess that it could have been steenbras.This spot is known for huge steenies.If the conditions are simillar again on Saturday I will be going there again.
Three people can keep a secret if two of them are dead  :thmsup"

I think this is fast becoming the thinking of many an angler... I posted catches and venues up till quite recently but have also decided to go the route of ensuring that backgrounds and locations are not shown or mentioned in my posts.
Title: Re: Sharing of fishing spots
Post by: Marthin on August 05, 2010, 07:20:14 AM
Sakkie after reading your comments on my posts....

It's a difficult one.  On the one hand i agree fully with you, Ray, even the one other guy from the other site i used to have a tiff with about this very same topic.  On the other side few things in life give me greater pleasure than giving a new guy for example Lupo here ALL the information needed to get that first size fish.  I'll never forget the day Archar phoned me about fishing Bontkop, i told him when where and what tide, not to go that day but the next one, what bait etc to go.  When he called me 2 hours after getting there the next day with his first size kob of his life, i think i was prouder than him.

I don't keep spots secret, but i have also narrowed down the guys that i tell about fish.  You know the SSEC club, the group i tell might be bigger than most, but it's likeminded anglers with conservation at the centre of what they do.

I heard from a birdie that Ray caught the cows at Melkbaai.  I thought it was somewhere else.  Up to today i haven't told a soul even though i have a seriaas score to settle with a bovine sharkey...  Like i said in my initial post i disagree slightly from some views.  I won't tell someone of someone elses spot.... i will however share if i caught some fish at a certain place, i'll probably only get to fish in a month from then, but only to certain people.
Title: Re: Sharing of fishing spots
Post by: Sharkslayer on August 05, 2010, 06:08:57 PM
Marthin have a  :beer: .
I do respect your views and are sure that you have the utmost respect for our resources.

This summer you me and Loomis must make a plan to get you into that False bay Bronzies. :shkswm
Another month and i will start my hunt.
Title: Re: Sharing of fishing spots
Post by: Marthin on August 06, 2010, 07:08:42 AM
definately take you up on that!!!
Title: Re: Sharing of fishing spots
Post by: Fluffy on August 06, 2010, 08:33:58 AM
Marthin have a  :beer: .
I do respect your views and are sure that you have the utmost respect for our resources.

This summer you me and Loomis must make a plan to get you into that False bay Bronzies. :shkswm
Another month and i will start my hunt.
Think i will be hopefully joining you guys there
@ Marthin  I think i am meeting you tomorow....you going to maccassar tomorow?
Title: Re: Sharing of fishing spots
Post by: Marthin on August 06, 2010, 09:06:24 AM
correct.  Will see you there.... You just need to cut us some red bait early in the morning hehehehe

Wikus and I will do some worm pumping.
Title: Re: Sharing of fishing spots
Post by: Fluffy on August 06, 2010, 09:10:03 AM
correct.  Will see you there.... You just need to cut us some red bait early in the morning hehehehe

Wikus and I will do some worm pumping.
wouldve loved to but i am only going to be able to come at 8-9am
Title: Re: Sharing of fishing spots
Post by: Ray Hall on August 06, 2010, 09:48:35 AM
 :vryst:
Title: Re: Sharing of fishing spots
Post by: Spartacus on August 08, 2010, 09:49:58 AM
My 2c when I first started fishing last year Iput on another site "I am new to fishing does anyone mind if I tag along" a few guys responded and took me out fishing. 1)To show me the ropes and 2) Maybe to check me out and I belive once they had see what kind of person I was they took me to some of thier spots.
So in this way I learned alot about tackle, baits and got to fish some nice spots.
Title: Re: Sharing of fishing spots
Post by: LUPO on August 08, 2010, 01:28:52 PM
My 2c when I first started fishing last year Iput on another site "I am new to fishing does anyone mind if I tag along" a few guys responded and took me out fishing. 1)To show me the ropes and 2) Maybe to check me out and I belive once they had see what kind of person I was they took me to some of thier spots.
So in this way I learned alot about tackle, baits and got to fish some nice spots.

Spartacus, I think you have hit the nail on the head.   (clap)

I have and I am still doing exactly that and in so doing I have also had the privilage of meeting some extremely awesome people and talented fisherman.

I think it is also quite easy, if you have a spot that you might want to share with some of your friends on UA and not everyone, start making the people you trust or know as buddies under messages and send them a group pm. KLAAR!




Title: Re: Sharing of fishing spots
Post by: Walt on August 16, 2010, 09:34:14 PM
Yip,this can be a very sensitive issue.Firstly,I get inpired by actual pics of fish anglers catch,& derive pleasure from angler's catches,even if he catches next to me and I go blinkety blank,lol!

Therefore I'll post pics my of catches,with feedback on bait,equipt used,etc,and return some of that inspiration received.

BUT........................HOWEVER..................BUT & HOWEVER.............

My Modus Operandi for Catches follows some simple priciples:

a)I've made it a rule to never report back immediately so as to ensure that I don't ruin it for others who may fish these spots regularly.One's gotta offer respect to get some repect back in return.I sort of figure out when it's more or less apropriate if I want to offer feedback,and it could be a few days to a week's delay after catches were made,that I'd follow up.

b)Another Rule I follow, is to keep the location off the forum, away from the masses,courtesy of past occurrences!If the odd angler asks,I may consider sending him a pm,and request his silence in respect to others.These sites are about sharing,and by the time I've made a report,and sent pm,fish may be long gone already.

In the past it became apparent on angling sites that one can keep some happy,but it's impossible to keep the masses happy. If you refer to spot,some are happy,while others are beefing.And those that beef,I don't blame them in the least.Some anglers spend months scratching vast areas to find the ultimate spot,as has happened in Cape Point.It takes just one mention of spot on a site to get this spot totally exploited.All this angler's hard work gone down the drain.

Lastly,The Abovementioned have resulted  from my experiences from feedback with anglers,but I remain unbiassed,plus I always try & put myself in everyone's seat to get picture from all parties.

Title: Re: Sharing of fishing spots
Post by: Sharkslayer on August 16, 2010, 10:03:55 PM
Thank for the feedback Walt.
So Where is the belman biting? w;k w;k w;k (hit) :rotfl

Time that we wet a line together again.
Title: Re: Sharing of fishing spots
Post by: sea sick on August 16, 2010, 11:07:26 PM
 gents,
Ek hoor wat julle se. Ek ken ongelukkig nie die hele kuslyn nie. Hengel maar st lucia, cape vidal, mission rocks en tugela. Almal het toegang tot hierdie plekke. Partykeer kook dit daar met die vis. Wat ek egter meer geleer het op hiedie strande, is dat die lees van die water meer belangrik is as net die spot.

The sea changes constantly, so holes are here today and tomorrow the hole is gone, or has moved.
 w;k


So its is more up to the angler to make the right choice as what to do and where to put his bait.

I am discussing the catching of gamefish, which tends to always be on the move. It might be a whole different ballgame when targeting other fish.

Net my een sent, die ander eensent is gesteel

Ss
Title: Re: Sharing of fishing spots
Post by: rofflign on August 17, 2010, 08:44:51 AM
Yip,this can be a very sensitive issue.Firstly,I get inpired by actual pics of fish anglers catch,& derive pleasure from angler's catches,even if he catches next to me and I go blinkety blank,lol!

Therefore I'll post pics my of catches,with feedback on bait,equipt used,etc,and return some of that inspiration received.

BUT........................HOWEVER..................BUT & HOWEVER.............

My Modus Operandi for Catches follows some simple priciples:

a)I've made it a rule to never report back immediately so as to ensure that I don't ruin it for others who may fish these spots regularly.One's gotta offer respect to get some repect back in return.I sort of figure out when it's more or less apropriate if I want to offer feedback,and it could be a few days to a week's delay after catches were made,that I'd follow up.

b)Another Rule I follow, is to keep the location off the forum, away from the masses,courtesy of past occurrences!If the odd angler asks,I may consider sending him a pm,and request his silence in respect to others.These sites are about sharing,and by the time I've made a report,and sent pm,fish may be long gone already.

In the past it became apparent on angling sites that one can keep some happy,but it's impossible to keep the masses happy. If you refer to spot,some are happy,while others are beefing.And those that beef,I don't blame them in the least.Some anglers spend months scratching vast areas to find the ultimate spot,as has happened in Cape Point.It takes just one mention of spot on a site to get this spot totally exploited.All this angler's hard work gone down the drain.

Lastly,The Abovementioned have resulted  from my experiences from feedback with anglers,but I remain unbiassed,plus I always try & put myself in everyone's seat to get picture from all parties.

Well said Walt! I pretty much do the same, however I am never loathe to share my favourite blanking spots with others :hehe: maybe a new thread is required..."please share your favourite blanking spot" :fshie
Title: Re: Sharing of fishing spots
Post by: Walt on August 17, 2010, 09:09:25 AM
Well said Walt! I pretty much do the same, however I am never loathe to share my favourite blanking spots with others :hehe: maybe a new thread is required..."please share your favourite blanking spot" :fshie
Hahaha!Good one,Dave!But my 'blanking spots' will take up so much of Ultimate Angling's memory banks,I'll put Reefman/UA, BigTime out of bizness,and close 'em down,lol!

But I'll share one favorite blanking spot if you want to start some fun in a new thread.It'd be the Breakwater,in the Waterfront.While blanking you still have scenic Table Mountain in full view,Dolphins playing around on a good day,Cargo vessels,yachts,vessels constantly passing through,Robben Island in the distance,and this was a small piece of heaven until Bush put his spoon in.Pity!

Cheers!
Title: Re: Sharing of fishing spots
Post by: mad man on August 18, 2010, 03:53:41 PM
correct.  Will see you there.... You just need to cut us some red bait early in the morning hehehehe

Wikus and I will do some worm pumping.
when and were shark fish is for people that can not fish :hyst: :hyst: :hyst: :hyst: :hyst:
Title: Re: Sharing of fishing spots
Post by: REEFMAN on August 18, 2010, 04:35:15 PM
Hey madman Craig...  :welc: it's about time you got here!
Title: Re: Sharing of fishing spots
Post by: adam on August 18, 2010, 05:52:43 PM
thought I'll share a spot as.
SimplePortal 2.3.7 © 2008-2026, SimplePortal